COURT NEWS – 10-31-19

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent

         This week’s court news includes sentencings and a guilty verdict in a Baroda criminal sexual conduct case.

         A Benton Harbor man learned his fate last week after being convicted last month of second-degree murder and other charges in the 2018 shooting of his longtime girlfriend and the mother of his children. William Edwards was convicted by a Berrien County Trial Court jury in September.

         Edwards, 38, was arrested in Kalamazoo where he

William Edwards, 38,

had fled after the January 7, 2018 shooting of Novena Mathis in Benton Harbor. He claimed self defense and said he thought Mathis was reaching for a weapon when he shot her.

         Last week, Berrien County Trial Judge Gordon Hosbein sentenced Edwards to 72 years in prison-70 for second-degree murder and two years for the felony firearm charge. In addition to second-degree murder, Edwards had been convicted of possession of a firearm by a felon and carrying a concealed weapon.

         Also last week, Jason King, 45, of Baroda was found guilty of 10 counts of first, second and third degree criminal sexual conduct and one count of accosting a child for immoral purposes by a Berrien County Trial Court jury. The incidents occurred against underage females in Berrien County between September 2008 and September 2016.

         The case was tried before St. Joseph County Judge Paul Stutesman because all Berrien County judges disqualified themselves. They did so after questions were raised about the actions of then Chief Assistant Prosecutor Jennifer Smith in the handling of evidence. Smith is now a Berrien County trial judge.

         Judge Stutesman cleared Smith of any wrongdoing in April, saying that she had not acted in bad faith when she did not turn over evidence to the defense which ended up being misplaced for several months.

         King is scheduled to be sentenced on Dec. 4 in St. Joseph.

         In other sentencings, two people were sentenced to prison in Berrien County Trial Court on drug charges. In both instances, the people were arrested after undercover police officers bought heroin and methamphetamine from them.

         Robert L. Williams, 25, of Chicago, pleaded guilty to

Robert L. Williams, 25, of Chicago

delivery/manufacture of heroin less than 50 grams and was sentenced to three to 20 years in prison and $258 in fines and costs. He also faces charges in Illinois where he violated his parole.

         The incident occurred July 18 when Williams and another man met an undercover officer at the Niles Walmart in Niles Township. Charges of possession of a firearm by a felon and possession of a firearm in the commission of a felony were dismissed. He does have a warrant out from Illinois where he absconded from parole and is wanted for armed robbery.

         Defense attorney Edwin Johnson III noted that Williams has been diagnosed with a number of mental health problems after his mother was shot and killed in Chicago in 2017. “This man needs treatment and help,” Johnson said. “He’s bounced around since the loss of his mother.”

         Berrien County Trial Judge Charles LaSata disagreed. “You’re going to prison in Michigan and tell all your drug dealer friends not to come to Michigan or they’ll go to prison,” he said. “You were in trouble before your mother died, you deserve every day of your sentence. Tell your friends to not deal drugs in Michigan.”

         Tabitha Ann Stoneburner, 20, of South Thirteenth Street in Niles, pleaded guilty to delivery/manufacture of

Tabitha Ann Stoneburner, 20, of South Thirteenth Street in Niles

meth and was sentenced to 15 months to 20 years in prison. She must pay $258 in fines and costs.

         The incident occurred Aug. 6 at the Berrien Springs Speedway station on North Cass Street in Berrien Springs. Stoneburner sold meth to an undercover officer there as well as on other occasions in the Niles area.

         In other sentencings last week, a Lawton man was sentenced to prison in Cass County Circuit Court for his role in a marijuana growing operation that spanned three counties.

         Robert Alton Casper, 55, of Lawton, was the latest

Robert Alton Casper, 55, of Lawton

person to be sentenced in connection with a large tri-county marijuana growing operation. Casper pleaded guilty to conducting a criminal enterprise and received a sentence of three to 20 years in prison. He has credit for 409 days already served and must pay fines and costs of $3,048.

         Casper and three others were arrested Sept. 11, 2018 in connection with the marijuana growing operation. Search warrants executed that day found hundreds of marijuana plants being grown in two Cass County locations near Decatur and Dowagiac, two Berrien County locations in Benton Harbor and Berrien Springs and one location in Newago County.

         The leader of the operation, Joseph Lorello, claimed to be a medical marijuana caregiver and was sentenced last week on the same charge and received a prison term of 18 months to 20 years. Two other co-defendants, Vincent Lorello and Jorie Watkins, received probation sentences earlier last week for their role in the operation.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply