By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
ST. JOSEPH – A civil suit against the Berrien County Drain Commissioner and a Berrien County Commissioner has had ripple effects throughout county government in recent weeks.
The controversy goes back to a civil suit filed in July in Berrien County Trial Court when contractor Doug Hartzler sued Drain Commissioner

Christopher Quattrin, Berrien County Commissioner Teri Freehling and the estate of Freehling’s late husband, Patrick, who died in a farm accident in May.
Hartzler claimed Quattrin and Patrick Freehling devised a fraudulent scheme in which Hartzler’s company would do work for the drain commission while paying Freehling for the rental of equipment. Hartzler claimed that arrangement continued for two years but ended earlier this year, leaving him being owed money and no longer getting county drain jobs.
Hartzler also claimed that Teri Freehling should have recused herself from votes on drain work that benefited her husband. Freehling was appointed to the county board in 2015 and has been elected to two terms since then. She represents the Baroda area as well as Bridgman, Lake Township and part of Oronoko Township.
A hearing on the defendants’ motion for summary disposition to dismiss the case was held before Berrien County Trial Judge Dennis Wiley in early September. No ruling has been yet been made on that motion or if the case will proceed.
Last week, action came on two fronts. First, Berrien County Prosecutor Michael Sepic said he found no basis to press charges against Freehling on conflict of interest related issues. Secondly, the Berrien County Board of Commissioners with Freehling absent voted hire a special counsel to look into the matter for them.
Sepic noted that a complaint had been referred to his office questioning whether Freehling as a Berrien County Commissioner complied with the Contracts of Public Servants with Public Entities Act. That act requires municipal elected personnel to disclose financial interests in contracts between the municipality and, in the case of a county, a commissioner, which directly or indirectly benefits the commissioner.
That act says, in part, at MCL 15.323(2)(a), that a public servant shall promptly disclose any pecuniary interest in a contract to an official body that has the power to approve the contract. A violation of this act is a 90-day misdemeanor, Sepic said.
He reported that the complaint was investigated by the Michigan State Police. That investigation revealed that Freehling voted to approve payments by the county to Hartzler for work he was contracted to do on county drains. Payments by the county to Hartzler over a 2-year period reached over $400,000 with a “significant portion” making its way to Patrick Freehling.
Sepic said that while there’s evidence Teri Freehling knew of her husband renting equipment to Hartzler as she abstained from some votes paying Hartzler, facts uncovered in the investigation were insufficient to prove she knew the full extent of the moneys paid to her husband for county drain work. Such proof would be necessary for a criminal conviction, he said.
“Commissioner Freehling could have known and perhaps should have known the full extent of her husband’s work for Hartzler on county drain work,” Sepic wrote in a press release. “However, her actual knowledge, and her failure to disclose that knowledge, would be necessary in order to sustain a conviction … These factual and legal issues are simply too great to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.”
For their part, Freehling’s fellow county commissioners decided to retain retired Berrien County Trial Judge John Dewane to serve as a special counsel to insure the integrity of the board’s own by-laws and standards regarding conflicts of interest and to advise on any further action.

County Board Chairman Mac Elliott reported last Friday that he and county commissioners Bill Chickering, Jim Curran and Bob Harrison had met with Dewane to discuss the scope of his inquiry.
“We discussed the scope of his services,” Elliott said. “Although we appreciate that the criminal investigation has been concluded by the Prosecutor’s Office, the Board’s work is just beginning.”
“We anticipate that Special Counsel Dewane will undertake a complete review of everything that has transpired involving the allegations of Commissioner Freehling’s conflict of interest and the alleged failure to fully disclose the same. The investigative file has already been provided by Prosecutor Sepic, and Judge Dewane is presently going through it.”
Elliott noted that he asked Dewane to “follow the arrow wherever it points” and to advise the Board of Commissioners on any findings which may warrant the imposition of administrative sanctions as well as provide advice on possible amendments to the board’s by-laws. Dewane’s report is expected back in three weeks.
Elliott wasn’t the only county official speaking out about the matter. County Administrator William Wolf took off his “administrator hat” and spoke out in the public comment part of last week’s board meeting to urge the board to have the Michigan Attorney General review possible “criminal aspects of alleged serial corruption.” Board members did not act on his request.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.