By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
ST. JOSEPH – Solar energy has become a hot topic for several area townships and now even Berrien County has gotten involved. County Commissioners heard a presentation on solar energy and what local governments can do to control the development of solar projects at a recent county board meeting.
A number of area townships have either adopted new solar ordinances or are considering such a move. Pipestone Township in the Eau Claire area adopted not only a solar ordinance but also a wind ordinance in February. Others considering new solar ordinances include Buchanan Township, Berrien Township and Oronoko Township.
Two townships, Berrien and Lincoln Township near Stevensville, placed moratoriums on solar projects. In the case of Berrien Township, they want to have time to get a new ordinance in place and not worry about projects coming in before those rules and regulations are set.
The Pipestone solar ordinance permits solar farms as a special land use in the agriculture zoned district. It allows ground-mounted solar energy systems as a special land use in any district and building-mounted solar energy systems as a permitted use subject to a zoning permit in any district.
The intent of the ordinance is to “promote the use of solar energy within Pipestone Township as a clean alternative energy source and to provide for the land development, installation, and construction regulations for solar farm and similar facilities subject to reasonable conditions that will protect the public health, safety, and welfare.”
Michigan State University Extension Service representative Tyler Augst made the county board presentation which was attended by nearly two dozen people in person as well as more online via the county’s YouTube channel. He is based in the Extension Service’s Van Buren office and lives in Cass County.
Augst told commissioners that many resources are available for local governments considering such ordinances. He pointed not only to the MSU Extension Service but also the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy for everything from research and new information to sample ordinances.
He noted that the Michigan EGLE website has a variety of information for local governments to tap, including a frequently asked questions section and a database of what other communities around the state are doing.
“There’s a desperate need to begin planning for zoning for renewable energy,” he said. “For decades, there was little to no focus on energy planning. In 2021, 26 percent of zoning ordinances addressed large scale solar projects with 32 percent of ordinances addressing small scale solar projects.”
“51 percent of ordinances address large scale wind projects and 59 percent address small scale wind projects,” he added. “It’s vital to have communities make plans for wind and solar projects.”
“One of the things solar developers are looking for is guidance,” he said. “They don’t know the rules of the roads in the different townships. If townships can be pro-active, they can get out there and say what they will or won’t allow.”
He said solar ordinances can address a number of issues, including what zoning districts in which solar projects can be located, whether they are permitted in some areas and require a special use permit in others and what happens at the end of the solar installation’s life. On the last point, he said townships can require developers pay to remove installations.
He said interest in solar energy has increased through the years as people look to using renewable sources of energy and the costs associated with solar are declining. Costs have declined 90 percent since 2009, making projects much more viable for developers, he said.
He also said there’s enough sun in Michigan to do solar, contrary to what some think. “People ask if there is enough sun in Michigan to use solar and the answer is yes,” he said. “It’s not going to compare to the Southwest but northern states do have some sun.”
Augst also dispelled some ideas people have about solar. He said solar projects can be done in a variety of settings from rural to urban and that solar allows for more than one use of a property. He gave the example of the Midwest Energy site in Cassopolis where sheep graze alongside the solar panels.
He pointed out that ground-mounted solar installations can be found among fruit crops and around livestock, noting that installations with vertical panels require a smaller footprint.
Commissioners raised a number of questions and some acknowledged they had themselves or knew of other landowners who had been approached by solar project developers.
Commissioner Jim Curran asked whether townships can determine the locations of such projects through their zoning. Augst said townships can pick the areas most suitable for solar projects and then put down regulations.
“It’s up to local governments, but solar projects aren’t just something for industrial areas,” he said. “They could fit into agriculture districts with the appropriate standards.”
Commissioner Teri Freehling asked about the longterm impact on the land from solar projects. Augst noted that townships can write rules and regulations into their ordinances to require that companies put up bonds or lines of credit to cover decommissioning costs. Currently, the life span for solar installations are believed to be between 20 to 30 years.
The issue isn’t just one Berrien County municipalities are grappling with. Solar energy projects-as well as wind projects-have been the source of contention for the last few years in other parts of the state.
Just last month, voters in Cato Township in Montcalm County recalled board members over a wind ordinance that loosened restrictions on such projects. Meanwhile, township board members in Keene Township in Ionia County were recalled by people opposed to solar farms being allowed in the township.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.