BERRIEN COUNTY TRIAL COURT’S CASE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM UNDER SCRUTINY

BERRIEN COUNTY LOGO

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
ST. JOSEPH – The Berrien County Trial Court’s new case management system put in place this spring came under scrutiny and criticism at a recent Berrien County Board of Commissioners meeting.
The subject was first broached during County Commissioner Jim Curran’s report from the administration committee meeting. He reported that Berrien County Chief Public Defender Scott Sanford told them that their inability to access the new case management system has hampered the attorneys in his office.
Curran said that Sanford noted that the public defender’s office had previously been able to communicate via computer with the courts, the sheriff’s department, and the prosecutor’s office, before the new system was put in place.
“He said the way it’s set up now and in the future, they won’t be able to,” Curran told fellow commissioners. “It does create headaches but he said they are working through it.”
Commissioner Jon Hinkelman expressed concern about the situation. “It seems like a very difficult thing and something that needs to be solved,” he said.
Hinkelman’s and Curran’s comments led Board Chairman McKinley Elliott to expound on the situation and his frustration with the state in forcing the county to change from the case management system that had worked fine for years. He described it as trying to force a “square peg into a round hole.”
“The thing that frosts me is that in 1992 we developed the state’s first relational database for courts, the prosecutor’s office and law enforcement. That was 32 years ago,” Elliott said. “The state came down and said they wanted to see how we were doing this. They thought it was a great idea.”
“There are new people at the state now, they tell us that it was such a great idea that we’re killing it,” he added. “We no longer have a relational database and they say ‘no you can’t make one’. We could make another one-we could work with outside vendors and put together the software to make it happen. they won’t let us.”
“It is a quantum leap backwards, the courts didn’t cause it, the sheriff didn’t cause it, the prosecutor didn’t cause it, the state caused it,” said Elliott. “You would not run a private business this way. Private business is about efficiency in terms of your operation. This is not efficient, we’re not saving money or staff time, we’re wasting both.”
Elliott asked Commissioner Dave Vollrath, who is on a judicial advisory committee at the Michigan Association of Counties, to talk to people at the state. “All we need is for the state to loosen the reins and let us locally get back what we had,” he said.
“The sheriff knows how helpful it is to have all the different people: the sheriff, probation, the prosecutor and the judges’ offices to be able to see status of a file,” he added. “Imagine if MyChart (a program used by hospitals) suddenly went away and your doctor couldn’t talk with a specialist in Ann Arbor because someone says not going to do that anymore.”
“You can’t make something like this up because no one would believe you that the state made a conscious decision to scrap something that worked very well, that was time tested and we couldn’t keep it,” he said.
He said that while the new state-mandated case management system might work in counties that didn’t already have a program in place, it hasn’t worked for Berrien County.
“For us, it has been nothing but trouble,” he said. “We couldn’t convince them that we had something better. I hope our legislators will take note of this and address it. The opportunity cost for bad decisions isn’t just a one-time thing but ongoing.”
Berrien County Trial Court Administrator Carrie Smietanka-Haney acknowledged after the county board meeting that the rollout of the new case management system hasn’t been as smooth as she or anyone else would have liked, but said things are gradually improving.
“There are certainly kinks in the new software that need to be ironed out,” she said.
She noted that the courts are now on separate software systems than the jail, prosecutor’s office and public defender’s office. “The jail, prosecutor, and courts previously shared the system that was developed locally over multiple decades,” she said.
“Each time one of those entities has gone live on its new case management system, a level of connectivity is lost which then means we must all learn to access information differently,” she added. “There are certainly hurdles that we have faced with the new system, one of which being the level of access we can provide to our justice partners.”
Smietanka-Haney said the court is actively working with the software vendor to rectify the issues. “Transitions to new systems are never seamless and this process has been no different,” she noted. “We appreciate the support and patience we have received from the county and our justice partners in getting through any backlogs and bumps in the road.”
The county board’s next meeting is Sept. 12 after two weeks of no meetings on Aug. 29 and Sept. 5.
-30-

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply