By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
ST. JOSEPH – Berrien County has ended its state of emergency related to the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic, but the virus is still affecting life here in Southwest Michigan, the rest of Michigan and the nation. It also continues to raise questions about individual rights in a time of pandemic and emergency orders.
A number of actions were taken last week in connection with COVID-19. In addition to the Berrien County Board of Commissioners choosing not to extend the county’s state of emergency, they approved paying a private company for software designed to help track COVID cases. Also, Gov. Gretchen Whitmer strengthened the state’s mask mandate.
Whitmer signed a new executive order on Friday, July 10 that requires everyone to wear a mask when they go inside a business or office as well outside in large groups of people. Businesses are now required to deny service to anyone not wearing a mask with just a few exceptions.
The mask executive order cited a number of studies showing that wearing masks can reduce the rate of COVID-19 infections and could save lives.
“Wearing a mask is an effective and low-cost way to protect ourselves and our families from a deadly disease. It should be—and is—the responsibility of every Michigander,” the order stated.
“This order reiterates that individuals are required to wear a face covering whenever they are in an indoor public space. It also requires the use of face coverings in crowded outdoor spaces. Most significantly, the order requires any business that is open to the public to refuse entry or service to people who refuse to wear a face covering.”
Whitmer’s order makes a willful violation a misdemeanor carrying a $500 fine and cites MCL 10.33 and MCL 30.405(3).
Opposition to the mask mandate has come from at least two areas: law enforcement and small businesses.
Van Buren County Sheriff Dan Abbot reported over the weekend that his department will not be investigating mask mandate violations. He said he had no plans to pull the department’s resources away from investigating crimes to investigate mask mandate compliance. He urged those wanting to make mask complaints to contact the Michigan Attorney General’s office or the Michigan State Police.
Small business leaders have also expressed concern with the executive order. The National Federation of Independent Business responded to Whitmer’s mask mandate by saying that small business owners will be in the crossfires of the controversy.
Businesses could face not only potential fines and the revocation of their business licenses but also could be in a possibly dangerous situation of enforcing the mandate and facing off with non compliant customers. NFIB officials also spoke of situations where one customer might say they can’t medically tolerate a mask and another customer turns in the business.
In Berrien County, officials said last week that the county’s state of emergency could end since trends in terms of COVID-19 deaths, hospitalizations and infection rates appear to be headed in the right direction.
“The trends in terms of covid cases, hospitalizations and deaths have been pretty good the last few weeks,” County Health Officer Nicki Britten said. “I do feel comfortable letting it (the state of emergency) sunset. I don’t think it will have an impact on our response.”
She called the ongoing pandemic a “fluid situation” and said the county can dial it back and forth as situations warrant. “I ask that we be prepared in coming weeks and months, it may become relevant again,” she said.
County Board Chairman Mac Elliott concurred. He said

those at the weekly emergency operations center committee meeting last week felt comfortable in letting the state of emergency end. He said the group will continue to meet every week to look at data. He can order an emergency declaration for up to seven days if necessary and have it then extended by the full board.
He said the covid coordinating committee will continue to meet once a week. That committee will be made up of the sheriff, the county administration, Britten, the undersheriff and county board committee heads. “The main thrust is to get information from Nicki and she can also brief full board,” he said. “Back in March, we were meeting every day, thankfully we are not now.”

Although county commissioners all agreed to end the state of emergency, they disagreed on paying an area company to provide software and website to monitor the health of county residents. The website will track and allow employers to report COVID-19 results.
A majority of the board did agree to hire KKzo, a website building company, to give the health department an online tool where area employers can report if any workers are having COVID-19 or similar symptoms. The contract calls for the company to get $65 an hour for a total amount not to exceed $7,670.
The controversy about hiring the company came on two fronts. First, commissioners learned that the company was hired in June even though the contract was never approved by the county board. New County Administrator Brian Dissette admitted a mistake was made with work started before county board approval and the situation has been corrected.
Secondly, commissioners had concerns about privacy and how the information would be used. Commissioner Ezra Scott said he’s concerned the reporting tool will violate people’s constitutional right to privacy. He had additional concerns about how the data is being stored and what is being done with it.
Britten said no data on individuals is being collected or kept and that information is being used only as a tool to help the health department better monitor the health of county residents. “This is all volunteer,” she said. “It has value to the businesses and gives us an idea of where hotspots might be.”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.