BUCHANAN WOMAN DIES IN COUNTY JAIL

Kiera Necole Haynes, 32, of Buchanan

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent

ST. JOSEPH – The recent death of a Buchanan woman inside the Berrien County Jail has once again put the spotlight on the jail and its operations.

Berrien County Undersheriff Chuck Heit reported last week that Kiera Necole Haynes, 32, of Buchanan, had been found unresponsive in her cell in the jail’s receiving area shortly after midnight on Monday, April 17. There were no apparent signs of trauma.

“Life saving measures were taken by jail staff and Medic 1 Ambulance but were unsuccessful, Heit’s press release stated. “The inmate had previous medical conditions and was currently lodged on drug charges.”

Heit reported that the Michigan State Police 5th District Special Investigation Section were requested to conduct an investigation into the death in coordination with the WMed Medical Examiner’s Office. The autopsy will be performed at WMed.

Prior to this incident, Haynes had been criminally prosecuted other times including in early 2022 when she was sentenced for resisting and obstructing police.

A number of inmates have died inside the jail over the years for a variety of reasons ranging from drug overdoses to suicides. Nationwide, the U.S. Department of Justice’s Bureau of Justice Statistics reported in late 2021 that there were 1,200 deaths in local jails in 2019, a number that has risen steadily over the years.

The Bureau of Justice report further stated that the local jail mortality rate in 2019 was 167 deaths before 100,000 inmates, which was up 11 percent from 2000 when the rate was 151 per 100,000. Suicide was found to be leading single cause of death in 2019, drug or alcohol intoxication were other leading causes of death.

With Haynes’ death while in jail custody, Berrien County Sheriff Paul Bailey said last week that he was limited as what additional information he could provide while the investigation is ongoing. “We asked the Michigan State Police to investigate this incident as an independent agency to conduct the investigation,” he said.

“An autopsy was conducted and there were no signs of any trauma found,” he added. “They are waiting on the results of several tests, one of which is toxicology which can take up to 120 days.”

He said that once the final autopsy report is completed and the Michigan State Police are done with their investigation it will be forwarded to the Prosecutor for review which is standard in all death investigations.

One thing that has changed over the last two decades is the introduction of more medical care for jail inmates.

Bailey said the jail now provides 24 hour medical coverage provided under a contract with Wellpath. “Part of the booking process is asking medical questions of each inmate,” he said.

That change in jail medical coverage has come in the decades since the August 2002 death of Niles Dr. David Speers in the jail. He had been arrested in July 2002 for drunk driving and then jailed for contempt of court after he was stopped a month later for drinking in violation of his bond conditions.

His family alleged that jail deputies did not respond to his medical distress caused by alcohol withdrawal and that he was found unresponsive in his cell and later died. The family sued the county and individual sheriff’s department employees and reached a $5.085 million settlement in 2007.

The sheriff’s department’s 2022 annual report noted that the department continues to contract with Wellpath for medical services. Wellpath provides services so that there is 24 hour medical coverage provided with a staff of nurses, mental health workers, physician assistants and a nurse practitioner as well as a doctor, dentist and psychiatrist.

As for the overall jail statistics, Bailey said the jail’s current capacity is 341 and the last time they were overcrowded was on December 18, 2022 when they had 342 inmates in the jail. The jail’s average daily population for 2022 was 337. Those incarcerated include those who have failed to make bond after arrest, are waiting for trial or have been sentenced.

The Berrien County Jail has also been in the news over the last year or so as county officials have discussed the need for jail infrastructure repairs as part of an overall county facilities assessment study.

County Administrator Brian Dissette noted that the facilities assessment study named the jail as one of three county buildings with the most critical needs in terms of the physical structure and operating deficiencies. The county has a total of 60 buildings it operates.

The study noted that the current jail consists of two buildings on the site next to the Berrien County Courthouse. The original building was constructed in 1952 with the addition constructed in 1970. It covers a total of 112,000 square feet and is a 341-bed facility.

The study identified $21.4 million worth of work that needs to be done over the next 15 years, with over $10.8 million of that needing to be done in the first five years alone. A December, 2022 fire caused by a 40-plus years old generator has caused additional problems and the need for even more repairs.

The study concluded that the choice comes down to spending the $21.4 million needed to pay for work over the next 15 years or construct a new jail which could cost as much as $70 million. Even if officials choose to build a new jail, the study noted that over $10 million will have to be spent to keep the current jail going until the new one is built.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply