STATE OF MICHIGAN
IN THE
BERRIEN COUNTY
CIRCUIT COURT
Case No. 24-0230-CZ-S
HON. STERLING R. SCHROCK
CITY OF NILES,
Plaintiff,
ROBERT WATTS; MARY KATHRYN WESTGAGE; ROBERT JOHN, DIEHL; DANIEL VICTOR DIEHL, JR.; JAMES ALLEN DIEHL; HOL1.,IE VALLANCE; and ANTHONY KIRK,
Defendants.
_______________________
Christopher S. Patterson (P74350)
David J. Szymanski, Jr. (P86525)
Dylan S. Armda (P87061)
Fahey Schultz .Burzych Rhodes PLC
Attorneys for Plaintiff
4151 Okemos Road
Okemos, Michigan 48864
(517) 381-0100
cpattersonPfsbrlaw.com
dszymanskiRfsbrlaw.com
darruda@fsbrlaw.com
There is no other pending or resolved civil action arising out of the transaction or occurrence alleged in the complaint.
COMPLAINT
Plaintiff, CITY OF NILES (“Plaintiff’ or “City”), by and through its attorneys, Fahey Schultz Burzych Rhodes PLC, submits the following for its Complaint against Defendants Robert Watts, Mary Kathryn Westgage, Bobbie John Diehl, Daniel. Victor Diehl, Jr., James Allen Diehl, Hollie Valiance, and Anthony Kirk (collectively, “Defendants”), and states as follows:
PARTIES, JURISDICTION,
AND VENUE
1. Plaintiff is a City in Berrien County with offices located at 333 N 2nd Street, Niles, Michigan 49120.
2. Upon information and belief:
a. Defendant Robert Watts is an individual and, upon information and belief, resides at 1427 Commonwealth Drive, Mishawaka, IN 46544.
b. Defendant Robert J. Diehl is an individual and, upon information and belief, resides at 3975 Kaiser Road, Three Oaks, MI 49128.
c. Defendants Hollie L. Valiance and Anthony W. Kirk are individuals and, upon information and belief, reside at 1115 Galien Buchanan Road, Galien, MI 49113.
d. Defendants Mary K. Westgage, Daniel V. Diehl, Jr., and James A. Diehl’s residences are currently unknown to Plaintiff.
3. Venue is proper because this litigation concerns property within Berrien County located at 616 N 5t Street, Niles, Michigan 49120. MCL 600.1605.
4. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this litigation pursuant to MCL 600.605 (subject matter jurisdiction), MCL 600.705 (limited personal jurisdiction), MCL 600.751 (in rem jurisdiction), and MCL 600.2932 (jurisdiction to determine interests in land).
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS
The Property
5. The City owns the property (the “Property”) (Parcel No. 72-3050-0074-00-7) legally described below:
Lot 74 H B HOFFMANS ADD TO NILES
6. Upon information and belief, the Property is an undeveloped grass lot located at 616 N 5th Street, Niles, Michigan 49120.
Mary and Daniel Diehl
and the Diehl Children
7. Prior to November 20, 1974, the Property was owned by Mary and Daniel Victor Diehl (collectively, “the Diehls”).
8. On November 20, 1974, the Diehls executed a contract for the sale of land
conveying the Property to Julia Mae Watts but no deed was recorded in connection with this transaction (Exhibit 1 — 1974 Land Sale Contract).
9. On or around May 4, 1984, Daniel Victor Diehl passed away.
10. On or around July 10, 1990, Mary Diehl passed away.
11. Following her death, Mary Diehl’s Last Will and Testament was entered into probate in Berrien County. The will provided that, excepting one specific gift not relevant to this matter, her estate be divided equally among her four children: Mary Kathryn Westgage, Bobbie John Diehl, Daniel Victor Diehl, Jr., and James Allen Diehl (“Diehl Children”) (Exhibit 2— Mary Diehl Last Will and Testament).
Julia Mae Watts and Robert Watts
12. As previously stated, on November 20, 1974, Julia Mae Watts was conveyed the Property by the Diehls.
13. On or around December 23, 2009, Julia Mae Watts passed away.
14. Julia Mae Watts did not have a will in Berrien County at the time of her death.
15. Following the death of Julia Mae Watts, an individual named Robert Watts became the title owner of record for the Property.
16. The only contact information that the County had for Robert Watts was a P.O. Box he shared with Julia Mae Watts: P.O. Box 482, South Bend, IN, 46624.
17. Using this information, Berrien County attempted to contact Robert Watts via certified mail following Julia Mae Watts’ death.
18. Consequently, between 2010 and 2013, property taxes were not paid for the Property.
2013 Foreclosure of Property
19. On August 10, 2012, a Berrien County official made a personal visit to the Property and affixed notice of a foreclosure action to a tree located on the Property (Exhibit 3 — 2012
Affidavit of Personal Visit to Forfeited Property).
20. On March 27, 2013, Berrien County attempted to notify Robert Watts, Julia Mae Watts (deceased), Mary Diehl (deceased) and Daniel Victor Diehl (deceased) to appear for a foreclosure hearing on the Property resulting from the unpaid property tax.
21. The mail sent to Robert Watts’ address was returned as “unclaimed” (Exhibit 4 — 2012 Notice of Foreclosure).
22. On April 24, 2013, the Court entered a Judgment of Foreclosure (Case No. 2012- 0176-CZ) against Robert Watts, and ownership of the Property was given to the Berrien County Treasurer (Exhibit 5 — 2013 Judgment of Foreclosure).
23. The 2013 Judgment of Foreclosure states that: “The Court finds that all parties entitled to notice and an opportunity to be heard have been provided that notice and opportunity, and that Petitioner complied with the notice requirements of MCL 211.78i, and that all interested parties have either actual notice or constructive notice of these proceedings” (Exhibit 5).
24. Robert Watts did not appear to contest the 2013 foreclosure.
2013 Conveyance of Property Following Foreclosure
25. On October 16, 2013, the Berrien County Treasurer executed a quitclaim deed conveying the Property to Hollie Valiance and Anthony Kirk (Exhibit 6 — Valiance and Kirk Quitclaim Deed).
2018 Foreclosure of Property
26. On March 1, 2018, the Property was forfeited to the Berrien County Treasurer due to unpaid property taxes.
27. On December 17, 2018, Hollie Valiance and Anthony Kirk were successfully notified of a Judicial Foreclosure Hearing regarding the Property.
28. On April 8, 2019, the Court entered a Judgment of Foreclosure on the Property (Case No. 2018-0139-CZ) and ownership of the Property was given to the Berrien County Treasurer (Exhibit 7 — 2019 Judgment of Foreclosure).
29. Neither Ms. Valiance nor Mr. Kirk opposed the 2019 foreclosure.
30. The 2019 Judgment of Foreclosure states that: “The Court finds that all parties entitled to notice and an opportunity to be heard have been provided that notice and opportunity, and that Petitioner complied with the notice requirements of MCL 211.78i and MCL 211.78k(1), and all interested parties had either actual notice or constructive notice of these proceedings” (Exhibit 7).
2019 Conveyance of Property Following Foreclosures
31. On or about August 20, 2019, the Berrien County Treasurer executed a quitclaim deed conveying the Property to the City (Exhibit 8 — City of Niles Quitclaim Deed).
32. In March of 2024, the City began negotiations with Green Development Ventures regarding a development project including the Property.
COUNT 1: QUIET TITLE
33. All previous paragraphs are restated in their entirety and incorporated herein by reference.
34. The Berrien County Treasurer obtained absolute title to the property following both the 2013 and 2019 foreclosures. MCL 211.78(k)(6) (fee simple title to property set forth in a petition for foreclosure on which forfeited delinquent taxes, interest, penalties, and fees are not paid within the statutory time limit will vest absolutely in the foreclosing governmental unit, and the foreclosing governmental unit will have absolute title to the property) (Exhibit 9 — General Property Tax Act (Excerpt)).
35. The City is a good-faith purchaser who purchased the Property in 2019 following foreclosure. Upon information and belief, Defendants may wrongfully claim an interest in the Property.
a. Upon information and belief, Robert Watts may claim an interest in the Property through inheritance from Julia Mae Watts. This claim is without right because Mr. Watts’ rights were extinguished by the 2013 Judgment of Foreclosure.
b. Upon information and belief, the Diehl Children may claim an interest in the Property because they each inherited an interest in the property following the death of Mary Diehl. This claim is without right because the property was transferred to Julia Mae Watts in 1974. Even if this Court decides the 1974 transfer was not effective, the Diehl Children’s rights were extinguished by the 2013 Judgment of Foreclosure.
c. Upon information and belief, Ms. Vallance or Mr. Kirk may claim an interest
in the Property because of their previous ownership interest. This claim is without right because Ms. Vallance and Mr. Kirk were properly noticed during the 2019 foreclosure proceedings and did not appear to contest it. Therefore, their interest in the Property was extinguished by the 2019 Judgment of Foreclosure.
36. The potential claim by Defendants on the Property has clouded title.
37. The City wishes to obtain clean title by order of this Court so that it may convey
the Property tO Green Development Ventures for future development.
38. The City has absolute title in the Property.
RELIEF REQUESTED
WHEREFORE, for the reasons set forth above, the City respectfully requests that this Court:
A. Order Defendants to release all claims to the Property and remove any potential
cloud on the title;
B. Quiet title to the Property to the City; and
C. Grant such other or further relief as this Court deems just and equitable.
Dated: September 18, 2024
Respectfully submitted,
Fahey Schultz Burzych Rhodes PLC
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Christop er S. Patterson (P74350)
David J. Szymanski, Jr. (P86525)
Dylan S. Arruda (P87061)
4151 Okemos Road
Okemos, MI 48864
(517) 381-0100
(12-19)
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.