COURT NEWS – 2-6-20

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent

As more and more “juvenile lifers” are sentenced to a term of years rather than life in prison without the chance for parole, questions remain as to what sentences they should be getting as well as what the new sentences mean for the families of those murdered.

That was in evidence last week with the resentencing of Robert Eugene

Robert Eugene Leamon III

Leamon III in Cass County Circuit Court. Leamon killed his pregnant girlfriend, Becky Stowe, in 1993 when he was 16 and she was 15. Both were students at Brandywine High School. Stowe’s disappearance went unsolved for more than two years before Leamon was arrested.

It wouldn’t be until 1997 when he was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole. He and other juvenile lifers received a reprieve from the U.S. Supreme Court in 2012 when the high court ruled that it was unconstitutional to sentence juveniles to life without parole except in rare circumstances.

Last week, Cass Circuit Judge Mark Herman resentenced Leamon to a term of 25 to 60 years in prison. The 25 year term was the minimum sentence he could have received. Leamon has served more 24 years in prison and could be eligible for parole within the year.

The judge’s sentence came despite impassioned pleas by Stowe’s sister and Cass County Prosecutor Victor Fitz who asked for a minimum sentence of 40 years in prison. “I have to balance the scales of justice,” the judge said. “Retribution alone is not justice and leniency alone is not justice.”

Fitz and Stowe’s sister, Cynthia Slates, argued unsuccessfully that Leamon should stay in prison for the rest of his life. “When I was 16, I knew the difference between right and wrong, I knew it was wrong to take another life,” Slates said. “He also knew it was wrong to kill another human being, he planned the crime only as a man would.”

“It doesn’t matter whether he’s changed, he did a heinous crime,” she added. “We had closure and now it’s opening the wounds again … Please with respect, consider the victims. Please don’t dismiss my sister’s life.”

With a picture of Becky Stowe sitting on the table in front of him, Fitz went over the gruesome details of the murder including how Leamon lured Stowe to the isolated spot where he had already dug a shallow grave. When Stowe refused to get an abortion, he snapped and broke her neck and then buried her-possibly still alive.

“He didn’t shoot or stab her because he didn’t want a bloody scene to clean up,” he said. “He broke her neck and buried her in a shallow grave when she might have still been alive. This was cruel and heartless and not the acts of a child but a man. I disagree with your ruling and wouldn’t be disappointed if you changed your mind.”

“We’re in dissent with the system,” he said. “We highly respect this Court but we continue to oppose your ruling …The system is on its head, it cares much more about the defendants than the victims and public safety. While he may not kill again, there is an increased chance that he will as he did it once.”

Fitz said afterwards that his office is still considering appealing Herman’s ruling to sentence Leamon to a term of years. He said the 2012 U.S. Supreme Court juvenile lifer ruling part of a very disturbing trend that focuses on the defendants and disregards the victims. He called Herman’s 25 year minimum sentence “very disappointing.”

For his part, Leamon gave an impassioned statement before the sentencing. “There’s no excuse for my actions, I’m deeply ashamed,” he said. “Becky’s life was precious … I am disgusted when I think of what I did … I pray daily for Becky and for peace for her family and for my family. I remain committed to help others make better choices.”

Defense attorney Sofia Nelson said that she firmly believes Leamon has been rehabilitated. “I know this man, I would be proud to have him as a neighbor,” she said. “He is proof that rehabilitation is possible.”

Several other juvenile lifers are still waiting to learn their fate in Berrien County Trial Court and Cass County Circuit Court. There’s only one other juvenile lifer in Cass County, Darnell Johnson, who is scheduled to have resentencing hearing at the end of this year on Dec. 17. He shot and killed a woman during a robbery at a laundry in Union in 1997.

There are a dozen juvenile lifers in Berrien County. Some, like Niles resident Dakotah Eliason who killed his step-grandfather in 2010 when Eliason was just 14, have been resentenced to a term of years. Others have had hearings and are awaiting rulings and still others have not yet had a hearing.

-30-

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply