By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
This week’s court news includes sentencings and a decision not to prosecute in connection with a 2018 fire that killed six people in a residential motel near Benton Harbor.
Berrien County Prosecutor Michael Sepic announced Monday that his office will not be authorizing any criminal charges in the July 2018 Cosmo Extended Stay Inn fire case. A woman and five of her young children were found dead July 28, 2018 after a fire destroyed the motel where they lived.
Sepic noted that firefighters were able to rescue the woman’s husband and one of their children along with other residents of the inn. The woman and five children were found in a second floor hallway but attempts to revive them were unsuccessful.
He said his office did not authorize any charges because no one was found to have intentionally set the fire or cause the deaths. He added that any actions taken by motel residents or not taken by the building owners in terms of alarms did not reach the level of criminal negligence needed to bring criminal charges.
Sepic said his office’s review and conclusions did not address any potential civil liability.
Several departments responded to the fire including Sodus, Benton, Royalton and Lincoln Township fire departments, the Berrien County Sheriff’s Department and the Michigan State Police.
In sentencings, area residents were sentenced to prison and jail in Cass County Circuit Court.
Paris Antonio Garcia, 19, of McOmber Street in Dowagiac,

pleaded guilty to possession of meth and fourth-degree fleeing police, both as a habitual offender, and was sentenced to four to 20 years in prison on the meth charge and two to four years in prison on the fleeing count.
The prison terms are concurrent. He must pay $1,616 in fines and costs and $315 in restitution.
The incident occurred April 19 on East Prairie Ronde and Rudy Road in Dowagiac. Garcia fled from police and struck a pole, injuring the passenger in his car. Police searched the vehicle and found meth and a meth pipe.
“This is your sixth and seventh felony convictions as an adult along with five as a juvenile,” Cass County Circuit Judge Mark Herman said. “You had just completed a year in jail when this happened.”
“The probation department is recommending a year in jail but I also have to look at protecting the public,” the judge added. “You did not take advantage of the programs available in jail and I don’t know why you would do it now. My greater concern is that you said you’re not interested in Swift & Sure, that shows you have no desire to change.”

Gregory Lee Carter, Jr., 30, of Pokagon Street in Dowagiac, pleaded guilty to breaking and entering a building with intent to commit larceny and was sentenced to 19 months to 10 years in prison. He has credit for 459 days already served and must pay $1,048 in fines and costs and $267.03 in restitution.
The incident occurred June 3, 2014 at Mantke’s Mini Mart in Dowagiac. Carter and three others broke into the market in the early morning hours and stole cigarettes and liquor. They broke into Niles area businesses later that day. Carter is currently in prison in connection with the Niles break-ins.
A Niles youth scheduled to be sentenced next week in Berrien County Trial Court was sentenced last week in Cass County for a probation violation.
Caleb Ringer, 18, of Huntly Road in Niles, pleaded guilty to
violating his September 2018 probation for weapons and drug charges and was sentenced to 270 days in jail with credit for 156 days already served. His probation was revoked. He can serve the jail sentence in any correctional facility.
He violated his probation by driving with someone who had a gun while he was out on tether. “There’s no joy in saying that his life continues to have a trajectory on a downward spiral,” defense attorney Greg Feldman said, who noted that Ringer is likely to get a prison boot camp sentence in Berrien County.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.