By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
NILES – Court news this week includes sentencings and a guilty verdict in a Benton Harbor area murder case.
William Edwards, 38, had been charged with open murder in

connection with the Jan. 7 2018 murder of Novena Mathis, the mother of his children. The shooting took place inside Mathis’ car and afterwards Edwards fled to Kalamazoo where he was later arrested.
Last week, a Berrien County Trial Court jury found Edwards guilty of second-degree murder as well as other charges such as possession of a firearm by a felon and carrying a concealed weapon after a three-day trial. Edwards claimed self-defense, saying he believed Mathis was reaching for a weapon when he shot her.
He is scheduled to be sentenced Oct. 21 before Berrien County Trial Judge Gordon Hosbein in St. Joseph. Edwards could receive a sentence of life in prison or any term of years.
In sentencings, a former Galien resident was sentenced for his role in a late November crash last year on U.S. 12 that claimed the life of an Andrews University graduate.

Thomas Joseph Doyle, 40, of South Bend and formerly of Galien, pleaded guilty to moving violation causing death and was sentenced in Berrien County Trial Court to one year probation, 90 days jail and $$645 in fines and costs.
He has credit for seven days already served and can serve the last 60 days of his jail term on tether. His probation terms also include 9 p.m. to 6 a.m. curfew, no alcohol and drugs and no driving of a motor vehicle.
The incident occurred Nov. 30 in Bertrand Township. Doyle was westbound on U.S. 12 near the U.S. 31 freeway interchange when he struck a vehicle coming off the freeway. The driver of that car, An-na Kim, 24, was killed in the crash.
Kim, a native of South Korea, was a graduate of Andrews University in Berrien Springs and in an internship with the Grand Rapids Symphony at the time of the accident.
Doyle initially was charged with driving while license suspended causing death which is a felony but pleaded to the moving violation causing death charge which is a misdemeanor.
“He’s very remorseful,” defense attorney Thomas Keller said. “If he could back in time and take it back he would. It’s unfortunate that he drove that day and a person died. It’s something he’s going to have to live with.”
“He was driving in excess of the speed limit,” Keller added. “The accident reconstruction showed that if he had been going slower, she’d be through the intersection and not be hit … This was a very poor exercise in judgment. Ms. Kim did pull out and he had no time to react.”
Berrien County Trial Judge Charles LaSata said that the accident involved excessive speed with no alcohol involved. “I’m sure if you could trade places, you probably would but you can’t,” he said. “She’s gone forever.”
Christopher Lee Jarvis, 47, of Fort Street in Niles, pleaded guilty to attempted assault with a dangerous weapon and was sentenced this week

to two years probation, 150 days in jail with credit for 58 days already served, 90 days alcohol monitoring tether and $1,198 in fines and costs.
He also pleaded guilty to refusing to have a DNA sample taken and was sentenced to a concurrent 150 days in jail with credit for 58 days served and $50 in fines and costs.
The incident occurred July 28 at a residence on Fort Street in Niles Township when he assaulted Brandon Cravens with a shovel handle. He later cursed and threatened police when they arrested him.
“You really are kind of a jerk when you drink alcohol,” Judge LaSata said. “This is the modus operandi for you. You have prior convictions for operating with a high blood alcohol level, resisting and obstructing police and multiple probation violations. If you keep up with this behavior, you may end up in prison in the future.”
Defense attorney Scott Sanford said Jarvis doesn’t recall everything that happened that day due to his intoxication. “This has been a real eye opener for him, he was surprised by his blood alcohol content level,” he said. “He hadn’t spent a significant time in jail before.”
A Dowagiac man who engaged in a road rage incident against a former girlfriend is going to prison after being sentenced last week in Cass County Circuit Court.
Travell Weakley, 28, of Third Avenue in Dowagiac, was convicted of

five counts after an August jury trial and was sentenced to concurrent terms of 20 months to four years in prison for assault with a dangerous weapon and credit for time served, 248 days, on four misdemeanor counts. He must also pay $1,748 in fines and costs.
The four misdemeanor counts were domestic violence, reckless driving, leaving the scene of a property damage accident and driving with a suspended license.
The incident occurred April 13 on Robinson Road near Cemetery Street in Cassopolis when he forced his former girlfriend off the road three times and attempted to force his way into her car. Police found the bumper of his car at the scene of the accident but didn’t find his car until later.
Chief Assistant Prosecutor Tiffiny Vohwinkle called Weakley a danger to the public. “He has three personal protection orders against him from three different women and has committed six assaultive crimes,” she said. “His actions in this incident could have killed her and others could have also been hurt. He deserves prison.”
“The evidence in this case was overwhelming,” Cass Circuit Judge Mark Herman said. “Not only did you hit her car, you hid your car, you lied and tried to get others to lie. There doesn’t appear to be any bit of remorse on your part. Your only concern is what you want.”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.