By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
Recent court news in Berrien County include a plea in a highly publicized Niles purse snatching from last spring and a delay in the trial of a Buchanan man charged with driving drunk and striking and killing a Berrien County Road Department worker last summer.
News also came recently from the Michigan Court of Appeals who ordered that a Berrien County juvenile lifer be resentenced for the murder of a St. Joseph area store manager over 30 years ago. The Court of Appeals vacated the life without parole sentence handed down for Efran Paredes, Jr. and ordered that he be resentenced.

A Berrien County jury convicted Paredes of first-degree murder in 1989 in the death of Rick Tetzlaff, an assistant store manager at the grocery store where Paredes worked as a bagger. Paredes was a juvenile at the time but was tried as an adult and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
U.S. Supreme Court cases in 2012 and 2016 have ruled that mandatory life without parole sentences for juvenile offenders are unconstitutional and constituted “cruel and unusual punishment” in most instances. Paredes was just 15 at the time he committed the 1989 murder.
Paredes is one of several Berrien County “juvenile lifers” who have been resentenced after the 2012 and 2016 U.S. Supreme Court rulings. In most instances, the juvenile lifers have been resentenced to a term of years after hearings where judges found mitigating factors to warrant the sentence reduction.
In Paredes’ case, Berrien County Trial Judge Charles LaSata handed down the same life without parole sentence after a 2021 hearing on the matter. Judge LaSata noted for example that Paredes did not come from an unstable home environment and that his conduct did not reflect the transient immaturities of youth.
The Court of Appeals’ opinion came after his attorneys argued that the judge’s decision constituted an abuse of discretion. The Court of Appeals judges agreed and ruled that the life without parole resentencing did not follow the framework set down by either the U.S. Supreme Court rulings or the corresponding Michigan Supreme Court rulings.
They noted that “the Miller proceedings are ‘not comparable to an ordinary sentencing hearing in which neither the prosecutor nor the defendant generally bears any particular burden.’ … Instead, the prosecutor bears the burden of overcoming a presumption that ‘LWOP (Life Without Parole) is disproportionate.’”
In Berrien County Trial Court proceedings last week, the man arrested in connection with a well-publicized purse snatching outside a downtown Niles church entered a guilty plea while the man accused of driving drunk and killing a Berrien County Road Department worker had his trial delayed.
Antoine Lamar Dallas, 33, of South Bend, pleaded guilty to one count of unarmed robbery. He had been

set to go to trial this month on the unarmed robbery charge as well as other charges of stealing or retaining a financial transaction device and being a habitual offender.
Berrien County Assistant Prosecutor Kate Arnold and defense attorney Kaitlin Locke said other two charges will be dismissed as part of the plea agreement in exchange for him pleading guilty to unarmed robbery.
Dallas will be sentenced June 5 at 8:30 a.m. in Berrien County Trial Court. The unarmed robbery charge carries a maximum penalty of 15 years in prison and Locke said she anticipates sentencing guidelines of between 50 and 100 months in prison.
The purse snatching took place outside of the New Journey United Methodist Church at Third and Cedar Streets on April 14, 2022. Dallas was riding a bike past the church and grabbed the purse of an 80 year old woman. She fell down in the incident. Dallas jumped off his bike and struggled with the woman to get the purse. He then rode off on the bike.
The incident made local news last spring as police released a surveillance tape of the incident in hopes of identifying her assailant. Dallas was eventually arrested after police tested his shoe that had fallen off in the struggle and DNA testing by the Michigan State Police identified him as the suspect.
The police report of the incident noted that Dallas used the victim’s credit card multiple times after the incident. He ended up being arrested last December in Peru, Indiana.
In court Monday, Berrien County Trial Judge Jennifer Smith accepted Dallas’ plea and revoked Dallas’ bond at Arnold’s request. Arnold noted that Dallas has a history of assaultive crimes in Indiana. His convictions there include five sentences for robbery dating back to 2009.
Locke argued unsuccessfully to allow Dallas to remain free on bond. She noted that he had been free on $10,000 10 percent bond since December with no problems. She said Dallas had agreed to plead guilty from the start, letting the process continue on to this point only so he could be there for his infant son who is still in the hospital.
Judge Smith said she wasn’t concerned as much about whether Dallas would show up for his sentencing than whether he poses a danger to others and noted his past convictions including prison sentences.

Taylor Ryan Johnson, 34, of Buchanan had been scheduled to go to trial also this month. He is charged with operating a vehicle while intoxicated causing death in connection with the death of Berrien County Road Department worker William “Mack” Isom, 57, of Baroda.
That charge carries a maximum penalty of 15 years in prison and a fine of up to $10.000.
The incident occurred July 20, 2022 on Red Bud Trail near Glendora Road in Oronoko Township. Isom had been working on cutting up a fallen tree which was in the roadway across Red Bud Trail when he was allegedly hit by Johnson’s car. Isom had worked for the road department for over two decades.
Police did field sobriety tests on Johnson including balance and blood alcohol levels. He was found to have a blood alcohol level of .194 at the scene and later had a blood alcohol level of.161 when tested at Lakeland Hospital in St. Joseph. Both levels are more than twice the legal limit.
Judge Smith agreed last week to adjourn the trial but told Assistant Prosecutor Jerry Vigansky and defense attorney Trevor Maveal that it would be the last adjournment she will grant. No new trial date has been set and no date has been set for a motion hearing in the case.
The motion hearing involves Maveal’s intention to bring in evidence regarding Isom’s actions that day as well as Vigansky’s motion to exclude that evidence.
Vigansky said that Maveal wants to bring in evidence to show that Isom failed to set up enough traffic safety cones to warn motorists when he was clearing fallen branches from the roadway. The argument would be that if more cones had been set up, Johnson would have more clearly seen them and stopped.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.