ST. JOSEPH – News has come this month in a couple of high profile court cases. In addition, a number of area residents have been sentenced in Berrien County Trial Court.
The St. Louis, Missouri man accused in the 2023 murder of a Niles man has been found incompetent to stand trial. Jamie Phillip Perry, 29, was recently found to be incompetent to stand trial by Berrien County Trial Court Judge Jennifer Smith.
James Phillip Perry, 29, of St. Louis, Missouri
The judge had ordered Perry’s forensic examination back in January after he had previously been bound over for trial on four felony charges including open murder. Berrien County Assistant Prosecutor Kate Arnold said Perry had been evaluated at the forensics center and found to be incompetent.
Arnold said Perry will now get treatment at the forensics center in order to get treatment to become competent. The matter will be reviewed periodically over the coming months, she said.
Perry faces four felony charges in connection with the Sept. 30 shooting death of Luke James Botica, 28, of Niles. He is charged with open murder, being a felon in possession of a firearm and two counts of use of a firearm in the commission of a felony. The shooting took place at Botica’s home in the 1200 block of North 12th Street in Niles.
In another high profile case, a Niles teen is back on track to face trial on first degree murder and use of a firearm in the commission of a felony charges.
Farries Deshawn Maxwell, Jr., of Niles
Farries Maxwell, Jr. is accused of murder in the last of the three sets of murders occurring in Niles in August-September of 2022. Maxwell is accused of killing the man who police believe killed Maxwell’s father in the first of murders.
The case had been on hold after Maxwell’s attorney appealed a judge’s decision to bind him over for trial. That appeal was dismissed and the case is back on the docket for trial late this year or early next year.
A Niles man who severely beat his girlfriend last December was sentenced to prison last week in Berrien County Trial Court at the Niles courthouse.
Brandon Patterson, 44, of Niles, pleaded guilty to two counts of assault with intent to do great bodily harm less than murder and was sentenced to two concurrent terms of 38 months to five years in prison. He
Brandon Patterson, 44, of Niles
has credit for 60 days already served and must pay $316 in fines and costs.
He was also sentenced to time served for two contempt of court charges from trying to contact the victim when ordered not to.
The incident occurred Dec. 4, 2023 at a residence in Niles. Patterson previously served a prison term in Tennessee for an assault on another victim there in the past.
The victim spoke before sentencing and said that the incident had badly affected her and her family. She said that she had been in a relationship with Patterson since September, 2023 and that the abuse had gone from emotional to mental to physical.
“I am a shell of my former self,” she said. “I’m not sure if I will ever feel safe and secure again. I feel no hope for my future any longer. I thought I was going to die. I had to convince him I wouldn’t go to the police to escape. He said he would kill me and police officers I told what he did.”
The woman said she had bruises and contusions from her head to her feet, was kicked in the face and had two bald spots where Patterson pulled out her hair.
Although Patterson apologized and he and his attorney noted that he had completed anger management classes, Berrien County Trial Court Judge Jennifer Smith said she was bothered by the fact that he violated his bond conditions twice by having contact with the victim.
“There’s no reason to believe your anger management course had any impact on you if you couldn’t control your behavior in front of a judge,” Judge Smith said. “You are a danger to any person you come in contact with in a relationship … This was a short relationship and you reached this level of violence.”
Lawrence Charles Vail, 42, of Niles, pleaded no contest to one count of third-degree criminal sexual
Lawrence Charles Vail, 42, of Niles
conduct and two counts of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct. He was sentenced to 120 months to 15 years in prison on the third-degree CSC charge and credit for time served, 249 days, on the two fourth-degree CSC charges.
He must pay $514 in fines and costs and register as a sex offender.
The incidents occurred between 2017 and 2022 in Niles Township and involved more than one underage girl. Vail blamed his actions on his alcohol use.
“You weren’t so drunk that you didn’t know what you were doing,” Judge Smith said. “You continued to drink knowing that this was something you might engage in … Your choice to drink was separate from your choice to do this. This was a selfish choice to engage in this behavior.”
Andrew Wallace Siciliano, 34, of Elkhart, pleaded guilty to third-degree fleeing and eluding police, unlawful driving away of an automobile and two
Andrew Wallace Siciliano, 34, of Elkhart
counts of assault with a dangerous weapon and was sentenced to four concurrent prison terms. He must pay $462 in fines and costs and $27,443 in restitution to K&R Construction.
He received a 29 month to 60 month prison term for fleeing and eluding, a 38 month to 60 month prison term for unlawful driving away of an automobile and two sentences of 29 months to 48 months for the assault with a dangerous weapon counts. He has credit for 82 days already served.
The incident occurred May 14 in Buchanan Township. Siciliano was barefoot and walked a long distance before stealing a truck from a construction company. He then rammed a number of police cars before being arrested.
Judge Smith said that while Siciliano has a large amount of restitution to pay, her main concern is the protection of the community and the protection of police officers. She noted that he had been out of prison for only a few days when this incident happened.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.