By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
The Michigan Supreme Court ruled last week that a Berrien Springs woman will be getting a new sentencing. A jury found Alana Gonzalez guilty of hiring a hit man to kill her ex-husband’s girlfriend in late 2021 in Berrien County Trial Court and she was sentenced in early 2022. Kalamazoo County Circuit Court Judge Pamela Lightvoet presided over trial and sentencing after Berrien County Trial Court judges recused themselves as Gonzalez’s ex-husband is the Trial Court Family Division Administrator.
Alana Gonzalez received a sentence of 10 to 40 years in prison for solicitation of murder at her January, 2022 sentencing before Judge Lightvoet. The charge carries a maximum penalty of up to life in prison and the judge handed down a sentence in the middle to high end of the guideline range.
Gonzalez, now 62, of Berrien Springs, was convicted of hiring Benton Harbor resident Quacy Roberts to kill Bonita Levi in March, 2020. Levi was dating Elvin Gonzalez, Alana’s ex-husband, at the time and is now married to him. Alana Gonzalez has been divorced from Elvin Gonzalez since early 2017.
The Michigan Supreme Court ruled Friday to reverse and vacate part of the January 2024 Court of Appeals ruling in the case, and also to remand the case back to Berrien County Trial Court for resentencing.
Specifically, the Michigan Supreme Court said that Judge Lightvoet erred in basing her sentencing decision at least in part on Gonzalez’s refusal to admit guilt and her insistence on proceeding to trial rather than accepting a plea.
The high court also said the Court of Appeals erred by upholding that aspect of her sentencing and their ruling relative to Gonzalez’s appeals of how offense variables were scored in the sentencing guidelines including the proportionality of the sentence she received. The high court vacated the Court of Appeals’ rulings on the scoring and the proportionality.
“As the prosecutor concedes, the court plainly erred by sentencing the defendant based, at least in part, on her refusal to admit guilt and her insistence on proceeding with the trial,” the high court stated.
The justices cited a couple of court cases as the basis of their ruling. “A court cannot base its sentence even in part on a defendant’s refusal to admit guilt.” People v Yennior, 399 Mich 892, 892 (1977). “Nor can a defendant be punished for exercising [her] right to trial.” People v Jackson, 474 Mich 996, 996 (2006).
In their January ruling, Court of Appeals judges had noted those cases but said a judge can “consider however, the defendant’s lack of remorse because a lack of remorse implicates the defendant’s potential for rehabilitation.”
They noted further the trial court “further felt that defendant did not understand that she was not the victim—she was the perpetrator who victimized numerous other persons through her actions. It stated that many people go through difficult experiences such as divorce without trying to hurt or kill someone.”
In her testimony at trial, Alana Gonzalez denied telling the man she hired to kill anyone. She acknowledged that it was a “stupid decision” to keep talking to the man and to give him money. She said her frame of mind at the time was one of grief and anguish after the breakdown of her marriage.
“I was in a 180 degree different place, that’s why I felt shame and remorse,” she said during her trial. “… I was overwhelmed. I was making decisions then that I absolutely wouldn’t make today.”
Relative to the scoring of offense variables, the Court of Appeals had ruled in January against Gonzalez’s assertions that errors were made in the scoring in a number of areas such as being the leader in a multiple offender situation, interference with the administration of justice and that she had a premeditated intent to kill.
The Michigan Supreme Court denied other aspects of Gonzalez’s appeal, saying “we are not persuaded that the remaining questions presented should be reviewed by this Court.” Gonzalez had appealed other issues such as the validity of the search warrant of her cell phone and that she had ineffective counsel.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.