By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
ST. JOSEPH – After 20-plus years in the courtroom, Berrien County Chief Assistant Prosecutor Jennifer Smith feels she’s well prepared to take on her new duties as a Berrien County trial judge. Gov. Rick Snyder appointed Smith last week to the vacancy left by the retirement of Judge Scott Schofield at the end of August.
“My career has prepared me,” Smith said in an interview with the Berrien County Record last week. “I’ve seen a lot of different things, no two cases are the same. I’ve dealt with emergencies and split decisions. It will all help me handle things as a judge.”
Smith is the second new judge to be appointed to the bench in Berrien County this

summer. Snyder appointed Macomb County Assistant Prosecutor Gordon Hosbein to fill the vacancy left after Judge John Donahue retired at the end of June.
Hosbein is a St. Joseph native and the son of attorney Gary Hosbein. The new Judge Hosbein began his new duties here in Berrien County Sept. 4 and has been assigned to the criminal division. A formal ceremony to swear him in is set for Friday, Sept. 21 in St. Joseph.
For her part, Smith said last week that she’s excited for the new opportunity. “It’s exciting, it’s a totally new adventure,” she said. “People always ask you if you want to be a judge some day and I never really thought of it until the last few years. I have a lot of respect for the judiciary and I see this as another way I can contribute.”
Smith is a native of Chelsea, Mich. on the east side of the state and is a double graduate of Wayne State University. She earned her bachelor’s degree in 1993 and her law degree in 1996. She started in the Berrien County Prosecutor’s Office in 1997 as an assistant prosecuting attorney and has served as the chief assistant prosecutor since 2013.
She will leave the prosecutor’s office Oct. 5 and take on her new duties as a judge Oct. 8. A formal swearing in ceremony will be held after that at a date yet to be determined. She said she has been assigned to the court’s Family Division which will be a new experience for her. Both she and Hosbein plan to attend the next “baby judges school” in January.
She acknowledged that it will be different to be a judge after more than two decades as an advocate. “I will miss working with victims and I will miss my colleagues,” she said.
“I think the cases I will remember the most were the sexual assault cases which went to trial,” she added. “In preparing for trial, you have the opportunity to spend a lot of time with victims and their families. It really allowed me to see the terrible impact on their lives. It also allowed me to give them a little closure on their way toward healing.”
“There are others that stood out for one reason or another, she noted. “Sometimes the facts were very unusual, sometimes the cases would linger in the court system for a long time, sometimes I wasn’t able to provide the victim with a just result.”
She said she’s gained insight into the life of a judge by watching the judges of Berrien County over the years, including the last few years when she was primarily assigned to Judge Schofield’s courtroom. “Some are faster, others are slower, they have different demeanors and deal differently with courtroom decorum,” she said.
While Smith carried a docket like any other assistant prosecutor, she did have the opportunity to choose some high profile cases to handle. One of the more recent of those cases was the Southeast Berrien County Landfill embezzlement case which ended with convictions and prison terms for both general manager Sonny Fuller and employee Terry Snow.
One thing that won’t change for Smith is her commitment to volunteer work. “It’s always important to be in the community and really important to serve in the community,” she said.
She is a member of the Southwest Michigan Human Trafficking Task Force and has served on the board of directors for the Safe Shelter and the Children’s Assessment Center. She is also a member of Lakeshore Youth Baseball and Softball Association. She, her husband Mike DenDooven and their three children live in Stevensville.
Praise for Smith came from both Gov. Snyder and her boss, Berrien County Prosecutor Michael Sepic.
“Jennifer is known locally as an outstanding attorney with a stellar work ethic and she will be an excellent addition to the Berrien County Circuit Court bench,” Snyder said.
While we will miss Jennifer’s excellent work as a trial prosecutor and her role as chief assistant, I am very pleased that she was recognized for her talents by the governor,” Sepic said. “The Berrien County bench will be getting a lawyer who has an excellent disposition, research skills and one who will endeavor to make good judicial decisions.”
Sepic said he will soon be appointing a new chief assistant prosecutor as well as hiring a new assistant prosecutor.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.