HUFFMAN TO STAND TRAIL FOR DEATH OF GIRLFRIEND

Huffman-James-ParkerST. JOSEPH – A January trial has been scheduled for a Niles man accused in the July death of his girlfriend. The trial for James Parker Huffman is now set for Jan. 24-26 in Berrien County Trial Court.
Huffman, 52, of South 14th Street in Niles, is charged with one count of first-degree murder in connection with the July strangulation death of his girlfriend, Angela Cluver. He will next be in court Dec. 6 for a case conference and Jan. 17 for a status conference before the trial.
Berrien County Trial Judge Scott Schofield bound Huffman over for trial last week after Defense Attorney Scott Sanford and Assistant Prosecutor Cortney O’Malley both withdrew motions they had made in late October after a half-day preliminary hearing.
Defense attorney Scott Sanford raised the possibility of mounting an assisted suicide defense at the end of an Oct. 24 preliminary hearing. Sanford claimed that Huffman is guilty of violating the Michigan assisted suicide law and not murder.
Sanford said Cluver had no defensive wounds on her body and there was no evidence of a violent struggle. He said if Huffman’s guilty of anything, it would be of assisting Cluver to commit suicide. That violation is a five-year felony rather than life in prison without parole which is the penalty for first-degree murder.
Sanford asked Judge Schofield late last month to add a count of violation of the Michigan assisted suicide law and the judge asked both him and O’Malley to submit information about whether the judge can add another charge.
The judge expressed skepticism in October over whether he had the authority to add charges. “I’m uncertain of my ability to do so,” he said. “No one elected me prosecutor. I’ve never been asked to do so in my 21 years on the bench.”
O’Malley reported last week that Sanford ended up withdrawing his motion after more research found that only the prosecutor’s office has charging authority.
O’Malley said she also withdrew her motion to add another count of felony murder as an alternative theory to premeditated first-degree murder. At the Oct. 24 hearing, she said she disagreed with the assertion that it was a suicide pact situation and sees the evidence as showing that he intended to kill her.
“She did not cooperate,” O’Malley said. “There’s no logical reason to tape her eyes and mouth or gag her for a suicide. He intended to harm her. The fact that he duck taped her hands and legs suggests he wanted to incapacitate her.”
Sanford said adding a felony murder charge was redundant. “It’s the same charge whether you’re claiming first degree murder by strangulation or murder in the course of a strangulation,” he said.
Last week, Schofield ruled there was enough evidence to bind Huffman over for trial. A preliminary hearing held in late October featured testimony about Huffman’s statements to police, Cluver’s autopsy and what police found when they searched the South 14th Street home.
Huffman walked into the Niles Law Enforcement Complex July 24 and told police that he had strangled his girlfriend, Angela Cluver, July 21 in a failed double suicide pact. Police then went to the home and discovered Cluver’s body which was in a state of decomposition.
Niles police said Huffman told them he attempted to kill himself several times over the weekend by cutting himself, suffocating himself by stuffing socks in his mouth and trying to electrocute himself. An examination of Huffman’s body on July 24 found no evidence of cuts, burn marks or any other injury.
Huffman gave police a number of different reasons on July 24 for the “attempted double suicide” including that Cluver had medical issues, there was family drama going on and they had financial issues.
As for whether any suicide note was found at the home, Niles police officer Kevin Kosten reported he found handwritten notes on the kitchen table saying “I killed Angela”, “sorry dude”, “call 911” and “get rid of notes.”

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply