By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
BUCHANAN – The ongoing dispute between Buchanan city officials and the Buchanan Downtown Development Authority doesn’t appear to be ending any time soon. The DDA board holds their next monthly meeting on Wednesday, Sept. 11 at 6 p.m. at the Buchanan City Hall.

Last week, Mayor Patricia Moore questioned the future of the DDA. She said she’s seen the DDA’s work change over the years, from completing safety and other infrastructure improvements to focusing more on façade improvements benefitting just a handful of owners.
“While I can’t predict the future of the DDA, I feel they have completed their mission,” she said. She added that she believes the DDA has failed to support events, promote the City and represent their constituents in recent years. She also questioned diverting money set aside for the Mill Alley project.
For his part, DDA Chairman Joseph Paolucci said last week that he hopes the City and DDA can work out their differences. In the meantime, he’s working with County officials to allow the DDA to reclaim $38,000 in remaining Andrews Farm Tax Increment Financing funds so they can be used on building and façade improvements.
“There’s a ton of work to do downtown,” Paolucci said. “We’ve done a lot of work but there’s more that needs to be done.”
He said the reclamation of the Andrews Farm funds as well as using funds set aside for the Mill Alley and streetscape extension projects will be discussed at the DDA’s monthly meeting next week. He wants more money available to spend on infrastructure and repairs and less on administration.
The City/DDA dispute has been simmering for a year or more but came out into the open in June and has continued at the DDA’s July and August meetings. Differences between the City government and the DDA appear to be in a number of areas including access to information, autonomy and how much the City is charging the DDA for services.
The latest difference between the DDA and the City has arisen over the contents of a letter from an attorney commissioned by the DDA to review the operation of the DDA and its relationship to the City of Buchanan. That attorney, Eric Williams, of Big Rapids, is a municipal law expert and represents a number of municipalities in Michigan.
In his letter of July 30, Williams also responded to a July 9 letter to the DDA from Moore. Moore reiterated her view that the DDA has to reimburse the city for services rendered, including the time spent by City Manager William Marx serving as the DDA’s Executive Director.
The City’s billing for July alone totaled nearly $3,000. The DDA had been paying the City $8,000 a year for administrative services until the fiscal year starting July 1.
In her letter, Moore reported that she had asked City staff to calculate the time spent on handling DDA matters and providing services to the DDA. She wrote that the DDA would be invoiced on a billable hour basis which would “prevent any general taxpayer subsidizing of the DDA district which is not allowed by state statute.”
Williams disagreed, saying that no state law or city ordinance requires the City to impose a charge on the DDA or prohibits the City from spending money on the DDA or providing services within the district. He did note that City Commission can charge the DDA for its share of the costs for handling and auditing DDA funds.
He reported that the DDA Bylaws approved by the City Commission require City staff to provide support to the DDA but does not required that City staff be compensated for those services. State law also doesn’t require municipalities to charge DDAs for public services like street lights and street sweeping, he said.
With recent state law changes relative to Downtown Development Authorities, Williams called it a “particularly bad time” for the City to withdraw staff and administrative support from the DDA. He noted the new law contains a number of new provisions including new reporting requirements.
He pointed out that the City and the DDA should be working cooperatively together and called the current dispute “an illusory divide over the collection and expenditure of Buchanan tax dollars.” He noted that the DDA captures over $64,000 in taxes from properties in the district and the City another nearly $90,000 in taxes from the same properties.
His recommendation was for the DDA to ask the City to charge them for their share of auditing and accounting services for the 2019-20 year and then to have the DDA and the City Commission meet at least twice to iron out their differences.
Marx and Moore wouldn’t respond directly to Williams’ letter last week. They said last week that City Attorney Randy Hyrn is still reviewing Williams’ letter and they’ve asked him to give his legal opinion to the City Commission.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.