By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
NILES – Testimony came Monday from both an alleged victim of Buchanan attorney Lanny Fisher and a defense witness who called into question the testimony given by another alleged victim last month.
The case is being heard by Van Buren County District Judge Michael McKay after Berrien County judges recused themselves. He is expected to make a ruling on whether to bind Fisher over for trial on as many as 14 criminal counts by the end of the year.
Berrien County Prosecutor Steve Pierangeli requested at the end of Monday’s hearing that a transcript of the hearing be obtained and both sides able to submit briefs before a ruling is handed down.
Pierangeli said it could take two weeks to get the transcript. Once the transcript is received, both he and defense attorney Josh Blanchard would have three weeks each to submit a brief detailing their positions. Judge McKay would then issue his ruling on whether the state has provided enough evidence to warrant the case going to trial.
The hearing had begun Sept. 18 with four women testifying that Fisher had forced them to have sexual relations with them in exchange for his representation. Fisher faces 14 criminal sexual conduct and prostitution related charges. The incidents occurred over 12 years, dating back to 2010.
Monday, a fifth woman testified that Fisher had forced her to perform oral sex as payment for his representation of her. She said that the incident occurred in the summer of 2020 when she went to Fisher to represent her in on a domestic violence charge. Her grandmother dropped her off at Fisher’s office and he said he would take her home.
The woman testified that she told Fisher she didn’t want to go to jail and he told her he was a really successful attorney and could keep her out of jail. The woman said Fisher was “flirty” with her that day and asked what else she could do for him when she said she couldn’t pay him upfront. When she asked him if he was asking for something sexual, she said he told her “you choose.”
“He was my ride home,” she said. “I didn’t know how to get out of the situation, I felt helpless. I had trusted him, he had sympathized with me about my family, I felt I had to do it. He said ‘help me and I’ll help you’. I felt vulnerable.”
Questioning from defense attorney Melissa Freeman attempted to get the witness to say that the sexual interaction was consensual and that the witness chose what kind of “favor” to do for Fisher. Freeman also questioned why the woman went back to Fisher to handle another case in 2021.
The witness said she went back to Fisher because he had handled the first case which was in the same courtroom with the same judge. As for whether she could have chosen to do something else instead of a sexual favor, the woman said she felt like she didn’t have a choice.
The hearing concluded with the defense calling one witness. Adam Prescott was called to testify that he had had a consensual sexual relationship in 2020 with one of the four women who testified in September. He said the woman accused him of raping her which he said was false.
Prescott then said that the woman and her husband showed up at his home to accuse him in front of his wife. He said he denied the allegations and the woman agreed that he had not forced himself on her.
On cross examination by Pierangeli, Prescott admitted that his wife had called the woman but said she had not threatened her. Police were called because the woman alleged his wife had harassed her. The incident ended when the officer told the woman and her husband to leave.
Fisher was arraigned in April when he pleaded not guilty to nine counts of third-degree criminal sexual conduct, one count of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct and four counts of misdemeanor prostitution related offenses. The incidents allegedly occurred over several years, dating back to 2010.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.