PROPOSED LEGISLATION COULD CHANGE THE WAY BERRIEN COUNTY HANDLES JUVENILE MURDER TRIALS

EFRAN PAREDES, JR

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
The fate of “juvenile lifers” convicted of first-degree murder while underage is again in the spotlight, both here in Berrien County and around the state. Statewide, county prosecutors are opposing proposed legislation which rule out a life without parole sentence for any juvenile regardless of the circumstances.
In Berrien County, a former “juvenile lifer” has been resentenced to a term of life in prison without the chance for parole in a case that is likely headed back to the Michigan Court of Appeals.
Berrien County Trial Judge Charles LaSata resentenced Efran Paredes, Jr. to a life without parole prison sentence after the case had been remanded back to him from the Michigan Court of Appeals. According to published reports, Judge LaSata said Paredes hasn’t taken responsibility for the crime and has not been rehabilitated.
A Berrien County jury convicted Paredes of first-degree murder in 1989 in the death of Rick Tetzlaff, an assistant store manager at the grocery store where Paredes worked as a bagger. Paredes was a juvenile at the time but was tried as an adult and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
The Court of Appeals ordered in March that Judge LaSata resentence Paredes and stated that the judge had erred in 2021 when he initially resentenced Paredes to a term of life in prison without parole.
The Court of Appeals judges ruled that LaSata’s 2021 life without parole resentencing did not follow the framework set down by either the 2012 and 2016 U.S. Supreme Court rulings or Michigan Supreme Court rulings. They did say however that the legal standards at issue relative to the Michigan Supreme Court rulings had been unsettled in 2021.
U.S. Supreme Court cases in 2012 and 2016 have ruled that mandatory life without parole sentences for juvenile offenders are unconstitutional and constituted “cruel and unusual punishment” in most instances. Paredes was just 15 at the time he committed the 1989 murder.
Paredes is one of several Berrien County “juvenile lifers” who have been resentenced after the 2012 and 2016 U.S. Supreme Court rulings. In most instances, the juvenile lifers have been resentenced to a term of years after hearings where judges found mitigating factors to warrant the sentence reduction.
The legislation being proposed in Lansing would enact an absolute bar for anyone under 19 years of age receiving a life without parole sentence when convicted of first-degree murder, regardless of the number of victims who were killed and no matter how horrific the circumstances of their crime.
The legislation is being opposed by the vast majority of county prosecutors around the state including Berrien County Prosecutor Steve Pierangeli and Cass County Prosecutor Victor Fitz.

Berrien County Prosecutor Steve Pierangeli

Pierangeli and Fitz said they are joining most of the 83 State of Michigan county prosecuting attorneys in opposition to the juvenile lifer legislation poised to pass in the Michigan House and Senate.
“No matter the facts of the case, these proposed bills would make every person convicted of First-Degree Murder for an act they committed before their 19th birthday, eligible for parole release after just 10 years,” Pierangeli said. “County prosecuting attorneys across Michigan believe that these laws would be unfair to victims’ families and dangerous to our communities.”
“While it is a rarity, Berrien County has unfortunately experienced some very heinous murders by defendants under 19. This includes Tommy Richards, who committed a brutal sex assault upon a 10-year-old child and killed her before disposing of her body. Judges should have the ability to sentence defendants for these types of crimes to more than 10 years in prison at a minimum,” Pierangeli stated.
Fitz agreed and pointed out the horrific murders committed by persons under age 19 in Cass County. Examples he gave included the 1997 murders committed by Robert Leaman who killed and buried his girlfriend and by Darnell Johnson who killed one person and injured several others in a robbery at an area laundry.

Cass County Prosecutor Victor Fitz

“Each of these murders were planned well in advance of their execution,” he said. “If these proposed laws had been in effect at the time of these brutal slayings, the murderers would have been eligible to walk free a mere ten years after committing their horrendous crimes.”
Michigan prosecutors say the state already has a workable framework for ensuring that juveniles receive a fair and just sentence. Elected prosecutors from across the state, both Republican and Democrat, say House Bills 4160-4164 and Senate Bills 119-123 needlessly jeopardize public safety.
“Judges need the discretion to sentence as appropriate. This package of bills takes discretion away from judges to fashion an individualized sentence based on the facts of the case. And it is done at the expense of the victims’ families and public safety,” Pierangeli stated.
House Bills 4160-4164 and Senate Bills 119-123 are pending in the House Criminal Justice Committee and the Senate Civil Rights, Judiciary and Public Safety Committee, respectively. Pierangeli and Fitz encourage citizens to contact their local legislator to voice their opposition to these bills and to put communities and victims’ families first.
Current Michigan law allows a judge to sentence a juvenile murderer to life in prison without the possibility of parole in extremely limited circumstances and only after a hearing that takes into consideration the facts and circumstances of the case, including such factors as the background of the youth and the circumstances of the offense.
The proposed legislation completely overturns this; it does not allow for an individualized sentence, and it would absolutely prohibit a judge from imposing such a sentence, no matter how many people were killed or how horrific the murder might be, Prosecuting Attorneys Association of Michigan President-Elect Jeff Getting said.
If passed, Senate Bills 119-123 and House Bills 4160-4164 will eliminate even the possibility of life imprisonment without the chance of parole for defendants under 19, convicted of the most serious crime, first-degree murder.
On top of taking this sentence option away for the most egregious offenders, these bills further add insult to injury by allowing the state Parole Board to release such a murderer on parole after serving just 10 years.
Testifying before the State Senate, Getting, who is also the Kalamazoo County Prosecutor, said “We are in favor of juveniles having second chances, but we are also in favor of juveniles who have committed the most horrific acts facing the ultimate consequence of the possibility of life without parole. These bills take even that possibility away for the most deserving.”

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply