BERRIEN COUNTY “ROMEO & JULIET” UNDERAGE SEX CASE DRAWS TO A CLOSE

NILES – A local case that attracted national attention to the issue of how to handle “Romeo and Juliet” underage sex cases over the last three years has drawn to a close, but not without one last parting shot about the state of the judicial system from defense attorney Scott Grabel.

Grabel, a Lansing attorney, took over the defense of then Elkhart teen Zachery Anderson in 2015 after Anderson was initially convicted of fourth-degree criminal sexual conduct and sentenced to 90 days in jail, five years probation and placement on the sex offender registry.

Grabel successfully argued that the prosecutor’s office hadn’t lived up to a plea agreement that called for Anderson to get the benefit of a Holmes Youthful Training Act probation that would keep the conviction off his record.

After originally being sentenced by Berrien County Trial Judge Dennis Wiley, Anderson, now 22, ended up being resentenced by Berrien County Trial Judge Angela Pasula who gave him the HYTA probation status and took him off the Michigan Sex Offender Registry.

Anderson first appeared in Berrien County Trial Court in early 2015

Zachery Anderson
Zachery Anderson

after being arrested for having sex in December 2014 in Niles with a 14 year old girl he had met online on the “Hot or Not” dating website. Since then, the case has attracted attention for not only local media outlets but national ones such as the New York Times and Reason magazine.

Grabel didn’t mince words with his criticism of Berrien County Trial Judge Wiley, the Berrien County Prosecutor’s Office and the Elkhart County Adult Probation Office.         Anderson’s probation was supervised in Elkhart which is where Anderson lives.

The Elkhart probation office alleged that Anderson had violated his probationary terms by having contact with a youth under 18 and had him served with an arrest warrant last fall. Anderson ended up not being convicted of a probation violation but did have the probation extended.

Grabel noted that the contact was inadvertent and came when Anderson was at his parents’ home and his younger brother invited a 17 year old friend over for pizza. Another alleged contact came when a 17 year old girl started working with him on a technical team at Granger Community Church in Elkhart.

“I think this case has shown the immense failure of the judicial system to dispense fair justice considering the facts of this case,” Grabel said. “In my opinion the original judge, Berrien County Prosecutor’s Office, and Elkhart County Adult Probation Office are an embarrassment.”

Grabel said the whole case “shows the continuing problem when you have people trying to legislate their own personal morality.” He said he was glad “Zach as well as the whole Anderson family can move on with their lives and not have to deal with this situation any further.”

Last week, a third Berrien County judge, Judge Charles LaSata, presided over Anderson’s last probation review hearing and officially discharged him from probation. Anderson now no longer has to live certain distances away from schools and parks, can associate with youth under age 18 and have computers and smart phones in his home.

“We’re just happy,” Anderson’s father, Lester, said right after the hearing.

Lester Anderson said he and his wife, Amanda, had to educate themselves about the criminal justice system and their son’s rights over the last three years. Their son’s probation ended up turning their family’s life upside down as he had to follow rules such as not living within a certain distance of schools or in a household where there are computers.

“We did a lot of research,” Anderson said. “I tell parents to look at the conditions of probation. The courts have been ruling that a lot of them are unconstitutional such as banning the use of the internet or social media. What we learned was to pick our battles, we just wanted him to get through this.”

He said his son has been able to get through the last three years and survive. His son has been taking college courses and is 18 credits shy of having his associate’s degree.

Lester Anderson said his overall advice for parents is to be involved in their children’s lives and know what’s going on with them. He said he thinks the laws need to change when it comes to “Romeo and Juliet” type situations like his son’s where the relationship was consensual.

“The laws were made before today’s technology and they have to change,” he said.

Lester Anderson isn’t the only one saying that the laws need to be changed for “Romeo and Juliet” situations. American Civil Liberties Union attorney Miriam Aukerman noted in 2015 that U.S. federal courts were starting to rule parts of the Michigan sex offender registry law unconstitutional and arbitrary.

People and organizations across the country have argued that the existing criminal sexual conduct and sex registry laws don’t take into consideration “Romeo and Juliet” situations involving underage people having consensual sex. Defendants in such cases are treated the same as others who have criminal intent and actions, they’ve said.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply