ARE VIRTUAL MEETINGS HERE TO STAY FOR BERRIEN COUNTY MUNICIPALITIES?

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent

2020 was a year of change, due in large part to the COVID-19 pandemic. People’s personal, business and civic lives changed overnight and are still not back to normal.

Since March, people have had to deal with everything from lockdowns to on again, off again shortages of basic supplies. Workplaces have also been affected with some businesses deemed essential and allowed to operate while other businesses have struggled to survive after being forced to either close or have reduced operations.

For governments, the pandemic’s effects have ranged from fears of revenue cuts to concerns about how they would conduct business. Many local governments went from having their offices closed in the spring to being open with limited services and back to being closed at the end of the year.

Governments also had to find new ways to hold public meetings. With limitations on the size of indoor gatherings, local city councils, commissions, township boards and school boards had to become creative in how they reached constituents.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer issued an executive order early on in the pandemic to allow local bodies to hold virtual/remote meetings. That resulted in most governmental bodies finding ways to let the public attend meetings virtually through Zoom, Google Meet, YouTube and other social media platforms.

That executive order along with over 100 others Whitmer made during the spring, summer and early fall were overturned by the Michigan Supreme Court in October. Justices ruled that Whitmer had exceeded her legal authority by continuing to issue executive orders without the input or approval of the legislature.

That high court decision resulted in the legislature passing legislation temporarily amending the Open Meetings Act that Whitmer signed later in October allowing for virtual/remote meetings through the end of 2020. That legislation was extended last week to allow for governmental bodies to hold such meetings through March 31, 2021.

Whitmer noted in October that “By allowing for remote meetings, public bodies and residents can continue practicing safe social distancing while also ensuring meetings remain open, accessible and transparent to the public.”

Michigan Press Association Public Affairs Manager Lisa McGraw said in October that virtual meetings have worked well for the most part during the pandemic. She said one of her organization’s ongoing concerns have been making sure the public has the ability to participate in meetings and state their opinions.

The pandemic also caused a lot of changes in area courts. The Michigan Supreme Court ordered courthouses to close to the public in March. The State Court Administrative Office later unveiled a four step reopening plan local courts had to follow in order to be able to get back to holding jury trials and fully reopening.

Berrien County Trial Courts reached the third phase of the four phase plan for a short while in the fall and actually was able to hold some jury trials. They then returned back to phase one after a surge in COVID cases and deaths and remained there through the end of 2020.

Cass Courts were never able to go past phase two and officials were unable to conduct any jury trials despite making preparations to do so. They also suspended all in person hearings including jury trials through the end of 2020.

Both courts have said they will re-evaluate the situation in January as to when they might start a return to normal. In the meantime, officials have made provisions taking advantage of technology to make sure the public and the press have been able to access court proceedings.

In Berrien County, officials have used Zoom technology to allow attorneys and parties to appear remotely and have broadcast trials on the county courts’ YouTube channel. People can also visit the www.berriencounty.org/1058/Trial-Court website for information ranging from court dockets to video request forms.

In Cass County, officials have also utilized Zoom and YouTube to livestream court proceedings and allow attorneys and parties to attend proceedings remotely. People can find out more about what information is available at the www.casscourtsmi.org website.

COVID-19 didn’t stop some things in 2020. Elections went off with few glitches, albeit with many more people voted absentee than in a normal year.

The pandemic also didn’t stop local boards and commissions from making city manager and superintendent hiring decisions. In Buchanan, the City Commission and the Board of Education both conducted successful searches. They allowed people to participate remotely through surveys and virtual open houses as well as Zoom meetings and YouTube live feeds.

The Buchanan school district was the first to make a new hire this year. School board members conducted a six week search process which

NEW BUCHANAN SUPERINTENDENT, PATRICIA ROBINSON

culminated in the hiring of Patricia Robinson as the new superintendent. Robinson spent most of her career in the Benton Harbor school district where she was most recently the assistant superintendent.

Although COVID-19 restrictions forced meetings to be virtual, members said they felt they were actually able to gather more public input. In all, 247 people took the initial online survey and more than a hundred people tuned into the YouTube live feed for the interviews.

NEW CITY OF BUCHANAN MANAGER, HEATHER GRACE

The City Commission followed suit a few weeks later as they hired Heather Grace in early August to be the new City Manager. She succeeded William Marx who announced that he planned to retire more than a year ago. Marx stayed on to help Grace in the transition through mid-November.

Like school board members had done a few weeks earlier, most city manager candidates appeared in person for the interviews with the public able to watch remotely via Zoom.

The pandemic also didn’t prevent the Berrien County Board of Commissioners from hiring a new County Administrator in 2020. Like Marx, outgoing County Administrator William Wolf had announced last year that he planned to retire in June.

Wolf served as the county administrator for 15 years after previous stints as the county treasurer and the Benton Harbor mayor.

Commissioners had 15 people apply for the post but ended up interviewing just one candidate for the job, South Haven City Manager Brian Dissette. Dissette is no stranger to the county, having started his career in public administration as an intern in 2002 under former Berrien County Administrator Mike Henry.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply