BUCHANAN’S DOWNTOWN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY LOOKING TO SEPARATE FROM CITY

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent

        BUCHANAN – Recent membership changes on the Buchanan Downtown Development Authority has renewed debate on the DDA’s purpose and what its role should be within city government.

        The DDA is on its third board chairman in less than a year after Barbara Gordon took another job outside of Buchanan last fall and Sandy Huyvaert resigned this spring. Joseph Paolucci was elected chairman earlier in June. A new DDA director, Joe Krueger, was hired in February but resigned in May.

        The history of DDAs in Michigan goes back to the 1970s when the legislature established them as a way to spur business development in downtown areas. Once a DDA district is established, the authority can capture the increase in property tax revenue from business growth within the district.

        In Buchanan, the DDA has undertaken a number of projects over the years including giving out grants and loans to pay for building repairs and facade renovations in the downtown area. They have also lent money and support to others including the Farmers Market, the Buchanan Preservation Society and the Last Saturday concerts.

        Last week, DDA members and city officials met to discuss where the organization goes from here. Differences have arisen over the last several months and came to a head at the special meeting held June 25. DDA members have been asking for access to more information which in turn has led to talk of the DDA being autonomous from the city.

        “In the past, the board has been frustrated over the lack of access to information and transparency,” new DDA board chairman Joseph Paolucci said at last week’s meeting. “The city is leading on spending instead of letting the DDA lead.”

        Paolucci asked for and members approved seeking advice from an outside counsel on separating from the city. He said he’s been in preliminary contact with a Big Rapids area attorney. Board members set aside $2,000 for the attorney advice, $1,000 from the 2018-19 budget year and $1,000 from the new 2019-20 budget.

“There’s been talk of splitting into a separate entity,” he said. “Although it’s possible to do, I think we should receive advice from counsel before we do it. I’m an attorney and I know we shouldn’t move forward without the advice of counsel.”

        “We need to look at our relationship with the city, the city’s charging of fees and who controls the funds,” he added. “I don’t think the board understands its role and responsibilities. What I’d like to see is the DDA have a separate office but still be part of the city … There’s no reason to have a legal separation just because we want information and want to control our money.”

        Paolucci noted that the DDA is a group of volunteers and should be able to use city offices and services without charge like other city boards and organizations do. “We should be able to use space like other groups without cost, it’s unfair,” he said. “We’re being cut out of the city out of spite. It’s outrageous to be given two weeks to get our own attorney.”

        “We have a group of unpaid volunteers who are supposed to be responsible for TIF (tax increment financing) money, it’s preposterous,” he added. “This is like sending us down the river in a leady raft.”

        He said he wants to see more money spent on bricks and mortar and not on administrative costs. “We want to ensure that as much of the spending as possible is on making bricks and mortar improvements rather than subsidizing city hall,” he said.

        DDA member Penny Slocum-Correa said board members are frustrated with things not getting done and board members being kept out of the loop. “People come to meetings and to us and we don’t know what’s going on,” she said. “There were decisions we were supposed to be making and nothing came to us. There have been a lot of hard feelings.”

        “We questioned the $8,000 charge from the city in the budget,” she added. “We’re paying for services not rendered. Why is so much money going for things not accomplished? … We want to work with the city to make everything look better.”

        City Manager Bill Marx is serving as the DDA’s acting director as is required under state law. Mayor Patricia Moore is one of two city commission members on the DDA board along with Cameron Downey. They have a different take on the current dispute.

        Moore said during last week’s meeting that city officials were just following up on a request from Gordon, the former DDA chairman. “Your position is contrary to past members’ views,” she told Paolucci. “The city has tried to facilitate a possible separation and see what that means. People wanted their own director to save the costs the city was charging.”

        Marx didn’t speak much during the meeting but said later in the week that he tried to follow up on the separation proposal after Gordon and others said they wanted an office separate from the city.

        “I said we could work for that,” he said. “But I said by statute they would be responsible for the financials and would have to have a face to face meeting with the city commission twice a year.”

        He said all he and city commissioners want is to work together with the DDA but noted that the city needs to be reimbursed for the services it provides to the DDA. He blames the current situation on the “revolving door” of DDA members coming and going. Right now, there are two open seats on the DDA.

        “I look forward to them having their own counsel who is nonbiased, a person who can evaluate where they’re at,” he said. “In the present situation I look forward to the civility and conversation an attorney would bring.”

        “There is a great value to the DDA if they have a good focus on their mission,” he said. “Unfortunately, there has been a revolving door of members and an adversarial tone.”

        Marx said the city commission does have the authority to dissolve the DDA if they believe the DDA’s goals have been achieved. That would mean that the $65,000 or so the DDA captures in TIF revenue every year would go back to the city, the county and others like Lake Michigan College. For the city, that would mean $38,000 more in tax revenue each year.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply