By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
This week’s court news includes a ruling in a long running dispute over the Berrien County Sheriff’s Department Coloma area gun range as well as sentencings in Berrien County Trial Court and Cass County Circuit Court.
Berrien County Trial Judge Dennis Wiley ruled last month on the issue of attorney fees in the gun range case. The legal battle between the county on one side and Coloma Township and nearby businesses on the other had been going on for more than a decade.
The long battle between Coloma Township and Berrien County over the sheriff’s department desire to build a new gun range in the township had seemingly ended more than a year ago when the Michigan Supreme Court ruled they would not hear the county’s appeal against the township and a number of township business owners.
The court case has begun when local business owners took issue with the sheriff’s department using the range as they said it disrupted the wineries, u-pick farms and other tourist attractions in the area.
The Michigan Supreme Court had agreed in 2017 to hear an appeal by the Berrien County Sheriff’s Department of a September 2016 Michigan Court of Appeals ruling. The Court of Appeals ruled then that the county could not operate a shooting range in Coloma Township.
The Michigan Supreme Court ruled in 2018 that “On order of the Court, leave to appeal having been granted and the briefs and oral arguments of the parties having been considered by the Court, we VACATE our order of September 22, 2017. The application for leave to appeal the September 6, 2016 judgment of the Court of Appeals is DENIED, because we are no longer persuaded that the questions presented should be reviewed by this Court.”
Last month, Judge Wiley granted plaintiffs’ motion to have their attorney fees paid by the county as they had requested last fall. He denied their motion to have the gun range destroyed, noting that the county had stopped using the gun range per court order.
In sentencings, a Flint area woman who left three dogs in her truck while she gambled for several hours at the Dowagiac Four Winds Casino was sentenced to probation and community service. Two of the dogs died and a third was treated for dehydration.

Langford, 50, of Davison, Mich., pleaded guilty to three counts of attempting to kill or torture animals and was sentenced in Cass Circuit Court to two years probation, 90 days jail that can be served on tether, 250 hours of community service, $2,134 in fines and costs and $511.95 in restitution.
Under a plea agreement accepted by the court, Langford’s three felony convictions will be vacated if she successfully completes her probation and reduced to two misdemeanor counts of cruelty/abandonment of animals causing death.
During her probation, she cannot own or have unsupervised care of animals and cannot enter any casino, gamble online or purchase lottery tickets. Her community service is to be done at an animal shelter or animal rescue center. The restitution is to be paid to Cass County Animal Control which has been caring for the one surviving dog since April.
The incident occurred April 7 at the Dowagiac Four Winds Casino. Cass Chief Assistant Prosecutor Tiffiny Vohwinkle reported that casino surveillance cameras recorded Langford entering the casino around 8 a.m. that day and not leaving until 6 p.m. when police contacted her about the three dogs in her truck.
Defense attorney John English noted that Langford has no criminal record and did not intend to harm the animals. He said she has been going to Gamblers Anonymous. “She has very deep remorse for how the animals died and she has been punishing herself,” he said.
“I feel horrible and stupid and embarrassed to be standing here today,” Langford said. “I have a gambling problem. I love my animals, it was a horrible accident.”
Cass Circuit Judge Mark Herman called the incident a travesty. “You said you had left the window cracked and you had checked on them during the day and you hadn’t,” he said. “I’m sure you have punished yourself over and over. You were entrusted with the care of the animals and you gambled.”
“I believe you are remorseful and that you didn’t intend for this to happen,” he added. “But I am at a loss as to how you could forget they were in the truck. I can’t imagine getting so lost in gambling. I guess that’s what addiction does, it can make a liar out of a saint.”
Christopher Lee David, 51, of West
Main Street in Niles, pleaded guilty to fourth degree fleeing and eluding
police and was sentenced in Berrien County Trial Court to 60 days in jail with
credit for 10 days already served. He must pay $898 in fines and costs.
The incident occurred Feb. 9, 2017
and involved a police chase from Phillip and Niles-Buchanan Roads in Niles
Township south into Indiana where he crashed at Cleveland and Mayflower Roads.
He reached speeds of up to 110 miles per hour and at one point threw an object
out of his car that hit a police car windshield.

According to the police report, David had sent threatening texts to Mishawaka police indicating that he was prepared for a high speed chase and was armed with a handgun and sniper rifle.
Defense attorney Scott Sanford noted that David has already served a probation and jail sentence in Indiana for his action on the Indiana side of the state line during the 2017 incident.
“I made a big error in judgment that night,” David said. “It’s not something I normally would have done.”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.