By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent
BUCHANAN – Last week’s Buchanan Downtown Development Authority meeting featured both an overview of what the DDA has done in recent years and a continuation of the board’s ongoing conflict with city officials. A new state law requires downtown development authorities to hold a public information meeting twice a year.
In the public information part of the meeting, DDA Chairman Joe Paolucci noted the work the DDA has done downtown in the last decade, efforts that have helped renovate downtown buildings and revitalize the city.
“When I came here in 2006, I met Alan Robandt and learned about the DDA,” he said. “They had a grant program for windows and facades and the community was supporting development. We bought one, two, three and then four buildings and got on the bandwagon.”
“The initial spark was that initial program that sparked renewed activity,” he added. “The town does look dramatically different with people willing to invest and make things better. The DDA had a role in that and I would like to see it continue with the focus more on brick and mortar.”
Paolucci reported he received good news last week from Berrien County officials as they have agreed to a plan where the DDA can reclaim remaining Andrews Farm Tax Increment Financing funds for use to make downtown infrastructure improvements. Specifically, the funds would be used to make Mill Alley boardwalk and other repairs.
The public information part of the meeting also featured a recap of the highlights of the last year. Those include successful seasons for the Farmers’ Market and the Last Saturday on the Common Concerts as well as last year’s White Saturday activities, downtown beautification and two grant/loans to downtown building owners.
The grant/loans made in the last year were to Cameron Downey and Paolucci’s business, Buchanan Equity Partners. Each received a $5,000 grant and a $20,000 loan. Downey used his money to tuckpoint the back of his Front Street building and to build out Bucktown Nutrition. Buchanan Equity Partners used their money on restoring the Sweet Shop windows.
Paolucci said the DDA’s future goals include continuing to beautify the downtown, support the Farmers’ Market and Last Saturday on the Common Concerts, forego the Mill Alley project and use that money for a new grant/loan program. He also mentioned the possibility of hiring a part-time DDA director.
He noted that there’s been almost no interest in the current grant/loan program from other downtown property owners. The current program gives people money that is 20 percent grant and 80 percent loan.
“I don’t know what that means, whether we should make it more generous and more appealing,” he said. “I’d like to have us consider a program that focuses on windows and facades to increase property values. That would bring more money to the DDA and attract more visitors and investors.”
Last week’s regular meeting again came with controversies and conflicts as DDA members clashed with City Commissioners in attendance over everything from the purchase and installation of holiday greens downtown to the City’s still secret response to a DDA attorney letter regarding city charges.
The holiday greens dispute appears to stem from a disagreement between Paolucci and City Manager William Marx, who did not attend last week’s meeting. Paolucci and DDA member Penny Slocum noted that the Buchanan Garden Club in past years would buy the greens, the DDA would reimburse them and the city would install them.
That changed this year as Marx told Paolucci that it would cost $1,300 for the city crews to install the greens. Paolucci responded by saying that installing the greens has never been the DDA’s responsibility. Last week, DDA members acknowledged they had previously approved the cost of the greens but declined to vote on paying the installation costs.
“It’s a complete mish mash, the rules and explanations keep changing,” Paolucci said. “We have a difficult time and don’t know what the rules are … We don’t have a common set of facts, they’re always changing.”
Commissioners in attendance seemed to say the line item for the installation cost the city had previously paid in past years is no longer in the city budget because the DDA is no longer paying the $8,000 annual city services charge.
Commissioners Sean Dennison and Mark Weedon, both of whom are on an ad hoc committee formed earlier this fall to study the DDA’s future, also took issue with Paolucci’s communications with city officials. “If your emails don’t change, I will ask that you step down,” Dennison told Paolucci.
“I don’t think it’s appropriate to call me out in a public forum,” Paolucci responded.
DDA members and commissioners also wrangled over the status of the letter from City Attorney Randy Hyrns to the commission that responded to a letter from DDA hired attorney Eric Williams. Williams wrote this summer that DDA bylaws require City staff to provide support to the DDA but does not say that City staff will be compensated for doing so.
Mayor Pat Moore, who is one of two commissioners on the DDA board, said the Hyrns letter won’t be released until city officials see all the drafts of the Williams letter. “We asked for all the drafts and haven’t gotten them,” she said.
“We as taxpayers should be able to see Randy Hyrns’ letter and all his drafts,” Slocum reiterated. “What do you think we are hiding?” DDA treasurer Heidi Ott asked.
Paolucci said Marx and Moore have unilaterally made decisions on everything from what the DDA owes the city to what DDA members’ responsibilities should be. He noted that Marx has tried to put the new state reporting requirements on the DDA when they don’t have the access to the information they need to do so.
The DDA’s next meeting will be Wednesday, Dec. 11 at 6 p.m. at City Hall.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.