COURT NEWS – 11-21-19

By DEBRA HAIGHT
BCR Correspondent

Included in this week’s court news are a recent Michigan Court of Appeals ruling on a 2017 Niles murder case as well as arrests in the latest arsons at the Niles Walmart.

The Halloween arson was the fourth this year at the Niles Walmart. The earlier incidents occurred on April 26, June 13 and July 19. No suspects were identified in those cases and Berrien County Sheriff’s Department investigators are checking to see if any or all are related.

In the most recent incident, merchandise in the clothing department was set on fire in the early morning hours of Oct. 31. The store was evacuated and the Niles Township Fire Department quickly put out the fire and cleared the smoke.

A check of security cameras showed that the suspects appeared to be a white male and white female who intentionally set the fire before fleeing the scene in a dark colored vehicle.

Last week, the Berrien County Sheriff’s Department reported that two people had been arrested in South Bend. Sheriff’s deputies along with Indiana law enforcement personnel executed a search warrant and arrested Stephen Edward Taghon and Paula Marie Kryski in St. Joseph County, Indiana.

The two are in the St. Joseph County Jail awaiting extradition to Michigan. Taghon is facing preliminary charges of third degree arson, larceny in a building and third degree retail fraud. Kryski faces third degree retail fraud and conspiracy to commit third degree arson charges.

In a Court of Appeals ruling last week, denied a Niles man’s appeal of his 2018 first degree murder conviction for the death of his longtime girlfriend. The initial case as well as the appeal raised issues related to suicide and euthanasia.

James Parker Huffman, 53, of South 14th Street in Niles, was

JAMES PARKER HUFFMAN

sentenced in April 2018 to a mandatory term of life in prison without the chance for parole. He was found guilty earlier that year by a Berrien County Trial Court jury of killing Angela Cluver July 21, 2017 at their Niles home.

Huffman walked into the Niles Law Enforcement Complex three days later on July 24, 2017 and told police that he had strangled Cluver in a failed double suicide pact. Police then went to the home and discovered Cluver’s body which was in a state of decomposition. He claimed he tried but failed to kill himself.

Huffman’s suicide claim was dismissed by Berrien County Trial Judge Charles LaSata at Huffman’s April 2018 sentencing. LaSata called him “callous” and a “cold, calculated killer”. The judge noted that he had gotten worse scratches picking raspberries than Huffman had on his arms from trying to kill himself.

In his appeal, Huffman claimed that his attorney was not allowed to question witnesses about the victim’s alleged suicidal state of mind and financial difficulties. The appeal conceded that the victim’s consent is not a defense for first-degree murder, but his attorney stated that the consent question was relevant to show that it was not pre-meditated.

“However, defendant’s argument fails to make a logical connection to the proffered evidence of the victim’s intent to commit suicide and defendant’s premediated intent to kill without running afoul of Kevorkian’s prohibition of consent and euthanasia as a defense,” the Court of Appeals ruling stated.

“Defendant declares that the victim’s suicidal mindset was relevant to show when precisely defendant solidified his intent to kill the victim. However, although evidence of a motive is generally admissible … the proffered motive by defendant in this case is expressly prohibited as a defense. There is simply no relevancy to defendant’s proffered

evidence of the victim’s state of mind and intent to commit suicide.”

Huffman also appealed another trial court decision to exclude evidence that he said would show Cluver’s intent to commit suicide. The Court of Appeals panel disagreed, noting that the testimony exclusion did not prejudice him or warrant a mistrial being called and the testimony could in fact infer premeditation.

The final issue raised in his appeal was that the evidence was not sufficient for conviction and that the prosecution did not present evident showing that Huffman premeditated the homicide. “Defendant is wrong,” the Court of Appeals noted.

“This testimony tends to show that defendant’s act of killing was reasoned and thought out for some time before the act. Moreover, defendant admitted that his act of strangulation occurred for roughly five

minutes. Our Supreme Court has previously recognized that manual strangulation on its own may be sufficient evidence of premeditation for first-degree premediated murder.”

“In light of defendant’s admission that the strangulation of the victim occurred for five minutes, there is sufficient evidence of defendant’s

premediated intent to kill the victim even if a suicide pact existed,” the ruling concluded. “Additionally, the forensic pathologist explained that the victim suffered abrasions on the front of the neck and injuries in the mouth and gum line. He opined that these injuries occurred before the victim’s death. The evidence was sufficient to support defendant’s conviction.”

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply