SMC FILES WITH MICHIGAN COURT OF APPEALS ON A $10.4 MILLION PENALTY FROM OAG

SMC LOGO

It’s been a time of turmoil on a number of fronts at Southwestern Michigan College in recent weeks and months. Full-time faculty voted to unionize earlier this year and a recently released report from the Michigan Office of the Auditor General appeared to indicate that the college has not been following state rules concerning student workers.

The issue at the center of the controversy with the OAG office is whether the college must pay into the state teacher retirement fund for part-time student workers. The OAG claims SMC must do so and owes as much as $10.4 million in interests and penalties on the $388,600 not paid.

College officials say that the OAG report is wrong and the college does not owe money to the teachers’ retirement pension fund for part-time student workers as the state alleges. They have filed an appeal with the Michigan Court of Appeals of the Michigan Court of Claims’ decision in January upholding the OAG claims.

SMC President David Mathews called the $10.4 million figure an “intentionally inflammatory claim” for which the OAG provided no “responsible accounting” to back it up.  “The College … finds no basis for a total claim more than 25 times the amount of the claimed actual contribution amount,” he said.

Mathews claimed the college did not enroll student workers into thedavid-mathews-mathews-southwestern-community-college-college-b84821cae44d9361 teacher retirement system after getting “direct guidance” from the Office of Retirement Services (ORS) and seeing what other community colleges did. He said the college received a “clean audit” from the ORS in 2016.

The OAG report disagreed, saying that SMC officials knew by 2015 that they were not complying with state law. The report called the college’s explanations for its actions to be without merit and stated that SMC falsely certified that its reports to the ORS were in full compliance from 2011 to 2016.

A Facebook page went up in late February by a group called “Citizens Concerned about Southwestern Michigan College.” That group is calling for more transparency from college officials and is concerned that taxpayers will be on the hook if the courts decide SMC owes the money to the OAG.

College officials addressed at least part of the transparency concern late last week as they established a new set of pages on the SMC public website, www.swmich.edu, that gives people information about board of trustee meeting dates, meeting minutes and agendas and the college’s lawsuit against the OAG.

The new web pages can be accessed at swmich.edu/taxpayer-information, or in the main menu navigation under “About SMC.”

As for union efforts, a group of faculty members began making a push to form a union last fall. Full-time faculty members were given the chance to cast a paper ballot for or against unionizing over two weeks in January and a majority ended up voting in favor of a union.

The college’s decision last year to change the schedule to lengthen the fall semester and shorten the winter break served as a catalyst for forming the union. People said the move was unpopular with both faculty and students.

Organizers said it was the schedule change as well as other issues such as Mathews’ perceived “autocratic leadership style” and reports of his salary and benefit package that led a majority of faculty members to vote for the union.

Reports put Mathews’ salary and benefit package as totaling over $325,000 in 2015, more than his counterparts from bigger community colleges with a larger tax base. At the same time, SMC faculty pay was 27th out of 28 community colleges in the state and SMC students were paying some of the highest community college tuition in the state.

By DEBRA HAIGHT

BCR Correspondent

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply